
Yes, BestMoney is a legitimate online platform for comparing car quotes. It is not an insurance company itself but a licensed insurance agency and comparison service that operates in all 50 states. The core value of BestMoney lies in its ability to quickly provide multiple quotes from well-known carriers like Progressive, Nationwide, and Liberty Mutual, potentially saving you time and money. However, its legitimacy as a business doesn't automatically mean it's the perfect choice for every driver; the quality of your experience can depend on your specific needs and driving profile.
The primary advantage is convenience. Instead of filling out forms on several individual insurer websites, you provide your information once to BestMoney and receive a range of offers. This can be a huge time-saver. It's important to understand that BestMoney makes money through commissions from the insurance companies when a policy is purchased through their platform.
A potential downside is that the network of insurers may not include every major provider. For example, companies like State Farm and USAA typically do not participate in these aggregator platforms. Therefore, while BestMoney gives you a good snapshot of the market, it shouldn't be the only tool you use for comparison. Always cross-reference a few quotes directly from companies not listed on the platform.
Here is a comparison of some insurers you might find on BestMoney:
| Insurance Provider | AM Best Financial Strength Rating | Typical Customer Profile | Notable Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| Progressive | A+ (Superior) | Drivers with varied records, including high-risk | Name Your Price® tool |
| Nationwide | A (Excellent) | Families, multi-policy holders | On Your Side® review |
| Liberty Mutual | A (Excellent) | Urban drivers, young drivers | Better Car Replacement® |
| Travelers | A++ (Superior) | Homeowners, experienced drivers | IntelliDrive® usage-based program |
| The General | B (Fair) | Drivers needing SR-22, previously uninsured | Specializes in high-risk coverage |
Before using any comparison site, read their privacy policy to understand how your data is used. Be prepared for follow-up calls or emails from partner insurers. Ultimately, BestMoney is a legitimate and useful starting point, but finalizing your purchase should involve direct research and a careful review of policy details.

I used BestMoney last year when my old rate jumped. It’s a real site and it worked. I got three quotes in about five minutes. The cheapest one saved me over $300 a year compared to my renewal notice. Just know you’ll probably get a few phone calls after you sign up. I just told them I’d already chosen a policy and the calls stopped. It’s a solid tool if you’re in a hurry.

Think of BestMoney as a car shopping mall. It’s a legitimate building with different stores (insurance companies) inside. You can window-shop all the deals quickly. The catch is that not every brand has a store in this mall. You might find a great deal, but you could miss an even better one from a company that doesn't sell through malls. It’s a fantastic first step, but do a quick online search for a couple of big names you don’t see listed to be thorough.

As a legit aggregator, BestMoney's real value is data transparency. You see how different companies assess your risk profile, which reveals what factors they value most—be it your history, driving habits, or vehicle type. This insight is powerful. However, the algorithms are designed to steer you toward their partners. For the most comprehensive picture, use BestMoney for initial screening, then visit the websites of a few top-tier companies directly to fill in the gaps.

Sure, it's a legitimate service. But "legit" is a low bar. The more important question is whether it's effective. It excels at giving you a baseline for pricing, which is helpful. My advice is to manage your expectations. The quotes are estimates, and the final price can change after the insurer runs its full process. Use it as a research tool, not a final decision-maker. Always read the actual policy documents from the insurer before you switch or buy.


