The value of 17 Morgan silver dollars can vary dramatically based on several key numismatic factors, primarily the date, mint mark, and physical condition or grade of each individual coin. A precise valuation is not possible without assessing each of the 17 coins.
According to the provided PCGS Price Guide, the value for a single common-date Morgan dollar can range from approximately $31 in a low, circulated grade (like Good-4) to thousands of dollars for a high-grade, uncirculated specimen. The value escalates significantly for scarcer "key date" coins, such as the 1893-S, which can be worth over a million dollars in mint state condition. Therefore, a collection of 17 coins could be worth anywhere from a few hundred dollars to well over a million, depending entirely on its specific composition.
For a more practical baseline, one source provides a retail offering for a specific lot of 17 Morgan silver dollars. This lot is described as containing common dates from 1878-1921 in "Very Good" (VG) or better condition and is priced at $589.95. This equates to a per-coin value of approximately $34.70. This price point is representative of a bulk purchase of common, circulated Morgan dollars, where the value is closely tied to the base silver content plus a modest numismatic premium.
In conclusion, while a specific retail example shows 17 common, circulated Morgan dollars valued at around $590, the potential worth of any given set of 17 such coins is highly variable. A definitive valuation would require an individual appraisal of each coin's date, mint mark, and grade.
