Yes, the Subaru Forester is a reliable vehicle, particularly models from 2020 onward which show significantly improved dependability. With proper maintenance, a modern Forester can reliably exceed 200,000 miles. Its reputation is built on exceptional safety, standard all-wheel drive, and practical utility, though its reliability varies notably by model year.
Choosing the right model year is critical. The 2018 model (late 4th generation) and the 2020-2024 models (5th generation) are considered the most reliable. These years benefited from solutions to previous major issues like excessive oil consumption and CVT (continuously variable transmission) concerns. Conversely, certain years have documented patterns of problems and are best approached with caution. These include the 1998-2001 models (early generation issues), 2006, and the span from 2009-2015, primarily due to head gasket failures in older models and oil consumption in newer ones. The 2019 model year, while the first of the improved 5th gen, had a higher initial complaint rate related to early production teething problems.
For the current generation (2019-2024), owners report a generally solid experience. However, some common notes exist. A few owners mention the 2.5-liter engine can feel underpowered during highway merging. There have also been sporadic reports of windshield cracks, a trend noted across several Subaru models. Transmission behavior is a frequent topic; while major CVT failures are not widespread, some drivers describe its operation as hesitant or "rubber-bandy" during acceleration, which is more a characteristic of the transmission type than a defect.
Long-term reliability hinges on consistent, high-quality maintenance, especially for the unique horizontally-opposed "Boxer" engine. This design requires meticulous attention to oil changes—every 6,000 miles is a common recommendation—to prevent issues. Using the correct specification oil is non-negotiable. Other wear items like spark plugs and the timing chain, while durable, are more labor-intensive to service than in some conventional engines, which can translate to higher repair costs when needed.
Market data supports its lasting value. According to industry valuation guides like Kelley Blue Book, the Forester consistently retains a high resale value, often exceeding 50% of its original MSRP after five years, which is a strong indirect indicator of perceived reliability and demand. Major rating organizations reflect this. Consumer Reports gives the 2024 Forester a score of 84 out of 100 for predicted reliability, and J.D. Power awarded the 2025 model a High Quality and Reliability score of 83 out of 100. RepairPal ranks it slightly below some segment leaders with a 3.5/5 rating, noting average ownership costs, which aligns with the need for timely, sometimes specialized, maintenance.
