Can I appeal if the traffic light turns directly from green to red and I can't stop in time?
2 Answers
If you are at an intersection and the traffic light changes directly from green to red without a yellow light, causing you to run the red light because you couldn't stop in time, you can apply for an appeal. This is because, according to the traffic safety laws, traffic signals should consist of red, yellow, and green lights: red means stop, green means go, and yellow serves as a warning. Therefore, if you disagree with the traffic police's penalty, you can file an appeal. Below are the considerations for determining whether the yellow light was absent: 1. If the traffic light has a yellow light: If you simply didn't notice the yellow light flashing or the yellow light wasn't very visible during the day, you cannot apply for an appeal. These situations are not due to the absence of a yellow light, so even if you apply for an appeal, it will not be approved. 2. If the traffic light does not have a yellow light: This could be due to a malfunction where the yellow light isn't working or because it's obstructed by an obstacle, making it impossible to see the signal. If you are penalized for running a red light under these circumstances, you can apply for an appeal with the traffic police department. Generally, in such cases, the appeal will be successful. Moreover, if the traffic light is indeed malfunctioning, the traffic police department is likely aware of the issue internally and may not impose a penalty.
I remember when I first started driving, I also encountered a situation where the traffic light suddenly changed from green to red. That night, the road was slippery, and I was still dozens of meters away from the intersection when the light abruptly turned red. I slammed on the brakes, but the tires skidded, nearly causing a collision. Afterward, I was still shaken and went to the traffic police station to ask if I could appeal. They said such appeals are usually not accepted because traffic regulations require drivers to always pay attention to signal changes and slow down in advance. To file a reconsideration, you need to provide evidence of a malfunctioning traffic light or an unexpected incident, such as footage of the slippery road. But since that day, I’ve developed a habit: reducing speed when approaching an intersection and checking the countdown timer. This not only helps avoid tickets but also ensures safety. Drivers must anticipate risks while driving, just as instructors emphasize maintaining a safe following distance. The yellow light is meant as a buffer and warning, but many people ignore it. In short, prevention is key—if you encounter such a situation, stop calmly first. The chance of a successful reconsideration is low, but you can learn from it and improve your driving habits. After all, safety comes first.
