Why is coasting in neutral not recommended for automatic transmissions?

[LeJulianna]

The reasons why coasting in neutral is not recommended for automatic transmissions are: 1. When coasting in neutral, the engine operates at idle speed, which can damage the transmission; 2. The braking time and distance of the vehicle become longer, making it very unsafe. The steps to start an automatic transmission vehicle are: 1. Turn the ignition key to the power position; 2. Press the foot brake and shift the gear from P to N; 3. Release the foot brake to start the engine; 4. Warm up the vehicle while stationary; 5. Press the foot brake, shift the gear from N to D, and release the handbrake; 6. Gradually release the foot brake and smoothly press the accelerator to start moving. The gear positions for automatic transmissions are: 1. D stands for Drive; 2. R stands for Reverse; 3. P stands for Park; 4. L stands for Low gear; 5. N stands for Neutral; 6. W stands for Winter/Snow mode; 7. S stands for Sport mode.

[SanTucker]

Having driven automatic transmission cars for over two decades, I understand that coasting in neutral is a serious misconception. The main reason is that the oil pump in an automatic transmission is driven by the engine. When in neutral, the engine idles, causing the oil pump to rotate at a low speed, resulting in insufficient lubrication. This leads to rapid wear and even burning of internal gears and bearings. I've seen many car owners spend a fortune repairing their transmissions because of this, not to mention the risk of brake booster failure, which significantly increases braking distance and is extremely dangerous. Even if you're trying to save fuel, coasting in neutral does more harm than good. It's better to stay in D or a lower gear to ensure proper oil pressure and the ability to accelerate to avoid obstacles at any time. Remember, safe driving is far more important than saving a little fuel.

[LaneLee]

Back in my younger days, I loved speeding. Once, I tried coasting in neutral on a mountain road for some extra thrill, but the transmission got stuck and nearly caused an accident. The reason is that automatic transmission systems rely entirely on the oil pump for lubrication and cooling, and at idle speed, the pressure is insufficient, causing parts to dry grind and overheat. I also learned that reduced vacuum in brake assist makes the brakes harder and more difficult to control. Now, I always coast in D gear—not only does it protect mechanical components and extend their lifespan, but it also allows the electronic stability system to function properly, preventing loss of control. After making it a habit, my car has had far fewer maintenance issues.

[SanKimberly]

As an average car owner, I often hear that coasting in neutral saves fuel and money, but the reality is the opposite. Coasting in neutral with an automatic transmission can disrupt the circulation of transmission lubricant, accelerating internal wear. Once damaged, repair costs can run into thousands. Moreover, braking assistance weakens, leading to slower reactions in emergencies. Simply put, use D or L gear to control speed on long descents and avoid neutral. This approach ensures safety and peace of mind, protecting your car and reducing unexpected expenses—truly worthwhile.