Which is More Durable: Mechanical Gear Shift or Electronic Gear Shift?

[DiLilliana]

Mechanical gear shifts have a shorter lifespan compared to electronic gear shifts. The specific differences between mechanical and electronic gear shifts are as follows: Safety Aspects: Electronic gear shifts rely on computer assistance for shifting, requiring only a signal input. Electronic gear shifts are typically automatic, whereas conventional gear shifts can be either manual or automatic and are mechanical in nature. Although mechanical automatic gear shifts also use computer assistance for shifting, electronic gear shifts offer better cost-performance and stronger safety features. Operational Feel: Electronic gear shift levers are more effortless to use, have a better appearance, and offer more advanced technology, but they come with higher maintenance costs. On the other hand, manual mechanical gear shift levers provide a stronger sense of control. Internal Volume of Gear Shift Lever: The transmission manual control valve in mechanical gear shift levers is located at the traditional position of the gear lever. Electronic gear shifts use motors to replace manual operations, eliminating the need to consider spatial positions and movement directions. Only switches and wiring need to be arranged, allowing flexible placement of the gear lever. Additionally, they can be designed in various styles, such as rotary knobs or buttons. Design Aspects of Electronic and Mechanical Gear Shifts: Electronic gear shift levers offer more flexibility for designers. Car interiors are an unavoidable consideration when choosing a vehicle, and automakers are constantly seeking breakthroughs. Compared to mechanical gear shifts, electronic gear shift levers can be freely designed by designers, leading to various types such as "chicken leg" shapes, electronic buttons, and rotary knobs. Electronic gear shift levers are more compact. Mechanical gear shifts require many components for shifting, some of which are used to control various valves. With electronic gear shift levers, many mechanical structures are replaced by electronic components and wiring, significantly reducing the overall size of the gear lever. Electronic gear shift levers are lighter and safer. Mechanical gear shifting requires manual pushing and pulling by the driver, whereas electronic gear shift levers make operations simpler. Mechanical gear shifts offer better reliability and a more distinct shifting feel. Electronic gear shift levers are controlled by electronic components, which are less reliable than mechanical gear shift levers and lack the distinct shifting sensation of mechanical gear shifts.