Which is more difficult to test for, automatic or manual transmission?
3 Answers
Most driving test vehicles are manual transmission, so it's better to practice with a manual transmission. Automatic transmission cars, also known as "senior cars," are relatively simpler to operate, and generally, drivers who can handle manual transmission can operate automatic transmission cars. 1. The difference between manual and automatic transmission lies in gear shifting. Manual transmission requires controlling the clutch to shift gears, and lack of coordination between hands and feet can cause the engine to stall. Automatic transmission's clutch is controlled by a computer, so stalling is rare. 2. If you have an automatic transmission car at home, you can learn automatic transmission, as it is easier to practice and operate. 3. If you haven't bought a car yet or your family car is manual transmission, it's better to learn manual. Because once you obtain a C1 license (manual transmission), you can drive C2 (automatic transmission), C3 (low-speed trucks), and C4 (three-wheeled vehicles). Otherwise, with only a C2 license, you can only drive automatic transmission cars and cannot drive C1, C3, or C4 vehicles.
When I first learned to drive and took the driving test, I found that learning with an automatic transmission was much easier. You just need to focus on pressing the accelerator and brake, and steering properly, without worrying about shifting gears or the clutch. On the day of the test, I was extremely nervous, but the automatic transmission allowed me to concentrate fully on the road rules, and I passed smoothly. Manual transmission is different. My friend learned that and kept stalling, especially when starting on a slope—it was chaotic. During the test, nervousness makes it even easier to make mistakes, and the examiner is strict; releasing the clutch too quickly or shifting gears untimely results in immediate point deductions. Overall, manual transmission adds an extra coordination step, which is a big challenge for beginners, while automatic transmission is worry-free and effortless, making it easier to pass.
After driving for over a decade, I genuinely think manual transmission license tests are more challenging. You have to simultaneously control the clutch, accelerator, and gear shifting – one slight mistake and the engine stalls, creating super awkward moments during the exam. Automatic transmissions are much more user-friendly, eliminating all that hassle with straightforward basic operations. Beginners dread unexpected situations most, like frequent stop-and-go in congested areas where manuals tend to hesitate while automatics remain steady. Though most cars today are automatic, practicing manual for the test can sharpen skills, but when it comes to exam difficulty, automatics clearly have the upper hand with significantly less pressure.
