Where does the new Q5 fall short compared to the old Q5?
2 Answers
Here are the disadvantages of the new Q5 compared to the old Q5: 1. Transmission: The old Audi Q5L was equipped with an 8AT transmission, while the new model has switched to a dual-clutch transmission. However, the 8AT is superior in both reputation and performance compared to the new generation transmission. 2. Four-wheel drive system: The new model's four-wheel drive system is inferior to the old model's Quattro full-time four-wheel drive system with Torsen differential. Here is some additional information about the new model: 1. Chassis: It uses a front underbody guard made of resin and fiberglass composite, with an added aluminum foil plate for heat insulation at the transmission position. 2. Suspension: The rear suspension uses a conventional lower control arm, with forged aluminum technology and a semi-enclosed resin guard. Components such as the tie rod have been changed to iron material to balance the front and rear axle weight distribution.
Having driven the Q5 for over a decade, I feel the new model falls short in some driving experiences compared to the classic old version. For instance, in terms of handling, the old Q5 used hydraulic power steering with a weighty wheel that provided clear feedback during corners and high-speed driving, giving great confidence behind the wheel. The new model switched to electric power steering—too light and lacking road feel, almost like driving a toy car. Then there's the four-wheel-drive system: the old version featured a purely mechanical full-time quattro system that never slipped in mud or snow, offering rock-solid stability. The new model optimizes electronic intervention for higher efficiency but weakens off-road capability, feeling less assured on rough terrain. The body weight also increased by about 100kg, making acceleration feel sluggish and robbing it of that punchy thrill. I miss the old version’s robustness, especially for long trips where it felt more reassuring. Though the new interior is trendier, overall, the old model remains more iconic.
