
You can get full coverage car insurance directly from major national insurance companies, through independent local agents, or via online comparison platforms. The best option depends on your specific needs for price, customer service, and convenience.
Major National Insurers Companies like State Farm, Geico, Progressive, and Allstate are household names. You can get quotes and purchase policies entirely online or by phone. This is often the fastest route if you're comfortable comparing options yourself. Their websites are user-friendly and allow for easy policy management.
Independent Insurance Agents An independent agent represents multiple insurance companies, not just one. They can do the legwork of shopping your policy around to find the best combination of price and coverage from a variety of carriers. This is an excellent choice if you want personalized advice without contacting several companies individually.
Captive Agents and Online Marketplaces Captive agents, like those for State Farm or Farmers, work exclusively for one company. They can provide in-depth knowledge of that specific insurer's products. Alternatively, online marketplaces like The Zebra or Compare.com let you input your information once to receive quotes from several insurers side-by-side.
Here’s a quick comparison of common avenues:
| Provider Type | Examples | Key Advantage | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Major Direct Insurer | Geico, Progressive, Allstate | Speed and convenience | Tech-savvy users who prefer self-service |
| Independent Agent | Local insurance agencies | Personalized service, compares multiple quotes | Those who want a hands-off, advisory approach |
| Captive Agent | State Farm agent, Farmers agent | Deep product knowledge for one brand | Customers loyal to a specific major brand |
| Online Marketplace | The Zebra, Compare.com | Quick side-by-side comparison | Getting a broad view of the market quickly |
Your driving record, vehicle type, location, and credit score will significantly impact your final premium, so it's wise to get at least three quotes before deciding. Always read the policy details carefully to ensure the "full coverage" includes the liability, comprehensive, and collision limits you need.

Start online with a big name like Geico or Progressive for a quick baseline quote. But don’t stop there. Pick up the phone and call a local independent agent in your town. They’re plugged into smaller, regional companies that often have better rates than the giants you see on TV. I’ve saved hundreds just by letting an agent do the shopping for me. It’s free, and they explain the fine print.

Most people just go straight to the big online companies. What they miss is the value of a good local agent, especially after an accident. When my car got hit, my agent handled everything—calling the other insurer, arranging the tow, getting me a rental. That personal service is worth a few extra dollars a month, in my opinion. It’s about peace of mind, not just the lowest number.


