What Causes Weak Braking After Replacing Brake Pads?

[McJackson]

Newly replaced brake pads may fail to stop the vehicle properly because: the wear levels on both sides of the brake pads differ significantly, leading to uneven braking force. This can cause one side to lock up while the other side hasn't engaged fully, resulting in the car pulling to one side. Braking relies on intense friction between the brake pads and the brake drum. When driving through water, the wheels are almost entirely submerged, leaving a thin layer of water between the brake pads and the drum. This acts like a lubricant, reducing friction and making it difficult to stop the car. Additionally, water trapped inside the drum doesn't dissipate easily. This loss of braking occurs very suddenly. After exiting the water, repeatedly applying the brakes while driving will wipe away the water droplets between the brake pads and drum. The heat generated by friction will also dry them out, quickly restoring the brakes' original sensitivity. This phenomenon rarely occurs in cars with disc brake systems because the brake pads in such systems have a small surface area, and the disc is fully exposed, preventing water retention. Due to centrifugal force from wheel rotation, water on the disc will disperse automatically, ensuring the braking system functions normally. Many compact cars use a front-disc-rear-drum braking setup, which is why some brakes may fail or weaken significantly after driving through water.

[SanJason]

I also experienced weak braking right after changing brake pads. Upon checking, I found the issue might be with the brake fluid. If the system isn't properly bled during pad replacement, air can remain trapped, affecting hydraulic pressure transmission. Additionally, new brake pads require some break-in time - their surfaces may initially be unevenly smooth with lower friction coefficients, so unresponsive braking during the first few presses is normal. I remember once testing new pads immediately on the highway, only to find the brakes ineffective, which scared me into rushing back to the shop. Turned out the bleeder screw wasn't tightened properly, causing fluid leakage. My advice: after pad replacement, test at low speeds first, avoid hard braking, and pump the pedal several times to help the system adjust. If braking remains weak, check whether the brake fluid is overdue for replacement or insufficient - both can cause similar issues.

[NorahAnn]

I've had quite a few embarrassing moments when changing brake pads myself. Once after replacement, the brakes felt soft and weak. There could be several reasons, like not cleaning the caliper grooves during installation, where accumulated dust from old rotors interfered with new pad seating. Or the new pads' material might be too hard and not properly broken in, making them ineffective in the first few days. I once skipped the bleeding step too, just loosened the screws a bit without fully removing air bubbles from the system. Also, using cheap pads might result in poor wear resistance affecting overall performance. My advice for DIYers: use professional tools, gently pump the brakes a few times to bed in new pads before test driving. Regular checks of fluid levels and caliper condition can prevent such minor issues.

[Tammy]

It might be a bit surprising to experience weak braking after installing new brake pads, but in most cases, it's because the new pads haven't fully bedded in yet. In the first few days, you might feel like the pedal isn't as firm as expected, but the pads and rotors need to wear in to achieve optimal friction. Improper installation, such as forgetting to bleed the system or not checking the brake lines properly, can also lead to insufficient hydraulic pressure. Another possibility is that the brake fluid may have aged or become low, and wasn't adequately replenished during the pad replacement. I had the same issue last time I changed my pads, but after driving for a couple of days, it returned to normal—no need to panic. However, if the weakness persists, it's best to have a mechanic check for any issues with the calipers or master cylinder, such as sticking.