What Are the Reasons for the Differences Between Automatic and Manual Transmissions?

2 Answers
StBrynlee
08/30/25 2:06am
The differences between manual transmissions and automatic transmissions are as follows: 1. Different Principles: (1) Manual Transmission: The driver manually shifts the gear lever (shift knob) to change the gear engagement positions inside the transmission, altering the gear ratio to achieve speed changes. (2) Automatic Transmission: While driving, the driver operates the accelerator pedal as needed, and the automatic transmission automatically shifts into different gears based on engine load and the vehicle's operating conditions. It can automatically change gears according to the vehicle's speed and engine RPM. 2. Characteristics: (1) Manual Transmission: Stable performance, high transmission efficiency, and high fuel utilization. (2) Automatic Transmission: Easy to operate with flexible gear ratios. There are various types, including hydraulic automatic transmissions, mechanical continuously variable transmissions (CVT), electronically controlled mechanical automatic transmissions, and dual-clutch automatic transmissions. The transmission is connected to the engine via a clutch, allowing the transmission's input shaft to synchronize with the engine's RPM. 3. Transmission Efficiency: Due to the manual transmission's purely mechanical operation compared to the hydraulic transmission of the automatic transmission via a torque converter, there is a difference in efficiency, directly leading to variations in fuel consumption. For cars of the same brand and displacement, manual transmissions can save approximately 10% more fuel than automatic transmissions.
Was this review help?
18
4
Share
VanCaroline
09/11/25 6:20am
After years of driving, I believe the fundamental difference between automatic and manual transmissions lies in the operation method. Automatic transmissions eliminate the need to press the clutch for gear changes, making them particularly suitable for effortless driving in urban traffic jams; manual transmissions require manual operation of the clutch and gearshift, offering more active control. The reason? The accelerating pace of social development has led people to pursue convenience and safety. Manual transmissions originated from early automotive designs, relying on mechanical connections to improve efficiency, making them suitable for low-cost maintenance. With technological advancements, automatic transmissions utilize torque converters and electronic controls to reduce operational errors and enhance comfort. Especially for novice drivers, automatic transmissions lower the learning curve. However, manual transmissions have an advantage in precise control, such as faster RPM matching, delivering a more exhilarating driving experience.
Was this review help?
9
3
Share
Expand All
More Forum Discussions

What Lights Should You Use When Driving in the Rain?

Different lights for different rainfall intensities: 1. Use parking lights for light rain: When it starts to rain lightly and the sky is dim but visibility is still good, you should use parking lights. 2. Use headlights or front fog lights for heavy rain: When the rain is heavier, the rainwater itself obstructs visibility, and water splashed up from the road by the tires of vehicles ahead creates a mist that significantly impacts visibility. In this case, you should turn on your headlights or front fog lights. 3. Use rear fog lights during torrential rain: Rear fog lights should only be used when the rain is extremely heavy. Red taillights already have excellent penetration and can usually cut through heavy rain. Rear fog lights are very bright and are designed to penetrate thick fog. Using rear fog lights in normal rain conditions can easily dazzle drivers behind you, compromising their visibility and, consequently, your own safety.
9
2
Share

What is the difference between auto trading companies and 4S stores?

The differences between auto trading companies and 4S stores: 1. A 4S store is an authorized dealer of a brand; auto trading companies do not have manufacturer certification. (1) A 4S store is a sales outlet that integrates car sales, maintenance, parts, and information services. It can only sell a single brand of cars specially authorized by the manufacturer, and the manufacturer also requires unified design requirements for the store's interior and exterior. (2) Auto trading companies are not controlled by manufacturers and do not have vehicles for sale themselves. They source vehicles from wherever they are cheapest across the country, meaning auto trading companies have a wide variety of vehicle sources. 2. Auto trading companies offer lower prices, but the quality of the cars cannot be guaranteed. The prices offered by auto trading companies are cheaper than those of 4S stores because they source vehicles from the cheapest locations nationwide. This results in uncertainty regarding the source and quality of the vehicles, with some auto trading companies even selling inventory cars or problematic vehicles.
20
2
Share

How Often Should the Clutch Disc Be Replaced?

The clutch disc should be replaced every 50,000 to 60,000 kilometers. Methods to reduce clutch disc wear include: 1. Do not depress the clutch pedal unnecessarily when not shifting gears; 2. When decelerating, avoid depressing the clutch pedal too early. Wait until the vehicle speed drops to a reasonable range before pressing the clutch pedal to minimize clutch idling; 3. When parking, shift to neutral and release the clutch pedal to avoid adding unnecessary burden to the clutch; 4. Start the vehicle in first gear to utilize the initial torque, reducing clutch overload. Additional Information: Although the clutch disc withstands extremely high working pressure, its strong resistance to wear and high temperatures means its replacement cycle is not short. Symptoms indicating severe clutch disc wear and the need for replacement include: lack of acceleration power during driving, the engine revs increasing without a corresponding increase in vehicle speed, clutch slippage, and even the smell of burning.
5
1
Share

How to Deal with Scratches on a Car?

Methods for dealing with scratches on a car mainly include: 1. Scuffs. Apply a coating agent that matches the car body to the scratched area. The coating agent can be applied once, twice, or three times. The more times it is applied, the cleaner it will look, but it is also important to ensure uniform treatment across the entire car body. 2. Minor scratches. If the rust is not severe, start by using very fine water sandpaper dipped in water to gently remove the rust spots. Avoid sanding randomly; instead, sand in a straight line in the same direction. Once completely clean, apply a layer of primer. For new scratches, clean the area and apply primer directly. If the vehicle comes with a small can of original factory paint, wait for the primer to dry, then sand it smooth with water sandpaper and apply the original factory paint over the primer. If original factory paint is not available, purchase a touch-up pen and use it for coloring. 3. Small scratches. If it is just a very shallow scratch on the surface paint, immediately use a compound to treat it. Wipe in a straight line. Once the scratch disappears, use a finer compound to wipe again and then apply wax.
3
4
Share

What is the purpose of car maintenance?

The purpose of car maintenance is to keep the vehicle clean, maintain normal technical conditions, eliminate potential hazards, prevent failures, slow down the deterioration process, and extend the service life. Below are the relevant explanations: 1. Car maintenance refers to the regular preventive work of inspecting, cleaning, supplying, lubricating, adjusting, or replacing certain parts of the car, also known as car servicing. 2. Daily car maintenance is very important. Neglecting daily maintenance can not only cause unnecessary damage to the vehicle but also endanger driving safety. By being meticulous and thorough in daily maintenance, you can keep the vehicle in like-new condition and also stay informed about the technical status of various parts of the vehicle. 3. Contents of minor maintenance: Minor maintenance generally refers to the routine maintenance tasks performed at the manufacturer's recommended intervals or mileage to ensure vehicle performance. It mainly includes changing the engine oil and oil filter. 4. Intervals for minor maintenance: The interval for minor maintenance depends on the effective time or mileage of the engine oil and oil filter used. Different brands and grades of mineral oil, semi-synthetic oil, and full-synthetic oil have varying effective periods, so please follow the manufacturer's recommendations. Oil filters are generally divided into conventional and long-life types. Conventional oil filters are replaced along with the oil, while long-life oil filters have a longer service life.
3
3
Share

How Many Kilometers for the First Maintenance of a New Car?

Generally, the first maintenance for a vehicle is at 3000 kilometers or 5000 kilometers. Below are the relevant explanations: 1. Car maintenance refers to the preventive work of regularly inspecting, cleaning, supplying, lubricating, adjusting, or replacing certain parts of the car, also known as car servicing. 2. Modern car maintenance mainly includes the maintenance scope of the engine system, transmission system, air conditioning system, cooling system, fuel system, power steering system, etc. 3. The purpose of car maintenance is to keep the car clean, maintain normal technical conditions, eliminate hidden dangers, prevent failures, slow down the deterioration process, and extend the service life.
7
2
Share
Cookie
Cookie Settings
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.