What are the reasons for a thermostat failure?

[AsherDella]

Here are the reasons for a thermostat failure: 1. Due to prolonged warm-up time, the engine operates at a lower water temperature, causing combustion gases and condensed water on the cylinder walls to form acidic substances that corrode the cylinders; 2. Liquid fuel and water wash away the lubricating oil film on the cylinder walls and flow down to the oil pan, diluting the lubricating system's oil, leading to wear on the cylinder liners and piston components; 3. If the cylinder block has defects repaired with adhesive, excessive temperature fluctuations between cold and hot states cause frequent contraction and expansion of the cylinder block, which can lead to adhesive failure or detachment, resulting in diesel engine malfunctions. Additional impacts of a faulty thermostat include: 1. The engine cannot reach its optimal operating temperature; 2. Increased engine wear, shortening the engine's service life; 3. The oil cannot achieve optimal viscosity, increasing engine operating resistance; 4. The engine cannot operate at its normal temperature.

[OJasper]

Last time my car's temperature gauge was acting erratic, and it turned out to be the thermostat failing. The mechanic said nine times out of ten, this part fails because of coolant issues—using off-brand coolant or not changing it for years leads to rust and scale buildup, which jams the valve's moving parts. Also, in northern winters, cold starts can cause ice to form in the circulation system, cracking the valve body directly. And for aggressive drivers like me, frequent high-temperature situations in summer traffic jams, where the coolant temp often hits the redline, can cause the thermostat's internal wax element to overheat and retire early. Now I've learned my lesson—stick to the maintenance schedule and use OEM coolant, plus keep an eye on the temp gauge in traffic jams.

[WalkerRose]

Over two decades of repairing cars, I've dismantled hundreds of faulty thermostats and found that the most common issue with mechanical ones is spring fatigue. Especially in older models, when the spring weakens, it can't adequately control the wax expansion, leading to inaccurate valve operation. Another hidden culprit is tap water added by car owners themselves. Mineral deposits accumulate over time, sticking in the valve shaft gaps, and by the time it seizes up, it's often too late to clean. The most heartbreaking case was seeing an owner use a cheap aftermarket part bought from a discount app—the rubber seal lasted only three months before melting and leaking, which also ruined the cylinder head gasket. My advice: always opt for OEM thermostats and never mix tap water with coolant.

[Duncan]

During my last road trip, I encountered a stuck thermostat and had to pay 2,000 yuan for towing. The rescue mechanic taught me how to identify the symptoms: when the engine is cold, feel the hoses—if both the upper and lower hoses are hot, it means the valve isn’t sealing properly; if the engine temperature rises unusually slowly in freezing weather, there’s an 80% chance the valve is stuck in the open position. The main issue is corrosion—I’ve seen people pour windshield washer fluid into the coolant reservoir to save trouble, but the alcohol in it severely damages rubber seals. Also, avoid revving the engine hard during winter warm-up, as the sudden increase in water pump pressure can deform the wax pellet chamber. Now, I always get the cooling system checked before winter to avoid suffering on the road.