What are the differences between the Magotan and the Phideon?
3 Answers
The differences between the Magotan and the Phideon are as follows: 1. Different dimensions: The Magotan's exterior dimensions are 4866mm*1832mm*1464mm with a wheelbase of 2871mm, making it a standard B-segment car; the Phideon's exterior dimensions are 5074mm*1893mm*1489mm with a wheelbase of 3009mm, making it a standard C-segment car. 2. Different powertrains: The Magotan has three engine options, namely 1.4T, 1.8T, and 2.0T; while the Phideon has two engine options, 2.0T and 3.0T. The power levels of the two are not on the same level, and the Phideon features hybrid injection for superior performance. 3. Different transmissions: The Magotan uses a domestically produced DQ380 transmission with a transverse front-wheel-drive layout; the Phideon 2.0T model is equipped with a German-imported DL382 transmission, and the 3.0T model has a German-imported DL501 transmission with a longitudinal front-wheel-drive layout, with the high-end models featuring all-wheel drive.
I've driven the Magotan and also ridden in the Phideon, and the difference is striking. The Magotan is a standard mid-size sedan with a sport-tuned suspension, making it agile to drive and effortless to weave through traffic jams. But the Phideon is all about luxury—sitting inside feels like sinking into a plush sofa, with noise insulation on a whole different level; wind noise is barely noticeable at highway speeds. The Phideon's rear seats offer enough legroom to cross your legs, plus heating, ventilation, and massage functions, making it perfect for impressing clients. The downside is its over-5-meter body length, requiring multiple adjustments when parking in tight old neighborhoods. The Magotan's fuel consumption is quite economical at 7-8L/100km, while the Phideon easily hits 11L/100km in city driving, adding 4,000-5,000 yuan annually in fuel costs.
The core differences become clear when examining the chassis. The Magotan uses the MQB transverse platform with a horizontally-mounted engine for space efficiency, while the Phideon adopts the longitudinal MLB Evo platform (same as Audi A6) with a vertically-arranged engine for better weight distribution. The Phideon comes standard with air suspension, gliding over speed bumps like pressing on cotton, whereas the Magotan's stiffer suspension delivers a noticeable bump over road imperfections. Their drivetrain configurations also differ - the Phideon's top trim features 4MOTION permanent all-wheel drive for superior traction in rain/snow, while most Magotan models are front-wheel drive. Although both use 7-speed dual-clutch transmissions, the Phideon's DL501 can handle 500Nm of torque, making it more durable during aggressive driving.
