
Shifting to neutral at traffic lights is the correct approach for automatic transmission cars, and using the handbrake in conjunction enhances safety. Engaging N (Neutral) gear with the handbrake applied can be more fuel-efficient, as the passive wheel in the torque converter of the transmission remains in an idling state, not adding extra load to the engine, which naturally reduces fuel consumption. More detailed information is as follows: 1. Waiting at traffic lights in D (Drive) gear with the foot brake pressed means the passive wheel in the torque converter between the engine and transmission is fixed, creating a counterforce on the driving wheel, thereby increasing the engine's load. This can be understood as hindering the engine's operation. Consequently, the engine's ECU increases fuel injection, leading to higher fuel consumption, which is why you can observe a high instantaneous fuel consumption when the car is stopped. 2. It is not recommended to wait at traffic lights in P (Park) gear because shifting from P to D can sometimes cause the car to reverse, affecting the vehicle behind and potentially leading to a rear-end collision, for which you may also bear some responsibility. 3. Some vehicles now come equipped with an 'autohold' function, which is an automatic handbrake. After activating this function with a button press, the vehicle automatically applies the brakes once stopped, eliminating the need to shift from reverse or drive gears, keeping the vehicle in a parked state. However, not shifting into neutral still poses certain safety risks, such as the vehicle lurching forward if the accelerator is mistakenly pressed, increasing the chance of a collision. Additionally, the auto start-stop function is also suitable for use at traffic lights, helping to save fuel to some extent, and the engine, when turned off, does not emit exhaust fumes into the car.

I usually drive an automatic transmission car and don't shift to neutral at red lights. Modern car designs are quite intelligent - just keeping it in D gear while braking is sufficient. This allows the engine to enter an efficient idle state, and the auto start-stop system will activate to reduce fuel consumption. Frequently switching to neutral actually wastes fuel because the engine idles without doing actual work. From an environmental perspective, fewer gear shifts benefit emission reduction. I've also noticed that braking in D gear illuminates the brake lights, alerting following vehicles. Unless the red light lasts over a minute, like at some long intersections, there's no need to bother. Overall, shifting to neutral offers few benefits while adding driving burden and affecting acceleration. I recommend developing the D gear habit - it's simple and practical.

As a frequent driver, I believe shifting to neutral at red lights is not very safe. Keeping the car in D gear with the brake pressed ensures the vehicle is ready to respond immediately, avoiding potential rolling risks. Automatic transmissions are designed to simplify operations, and unnecessary gear shifts can easily distract attention. In case of a rear-end collision, being in D gear provides some cushioning protection. I've also noticed that the brake lights stay on when the brake is pressed, increasing visibility and reducing the chance of a rear-end collision. In the long run, safe driving habits are key; shifting to neutral offers no additional advantages and may instead increase the likelihood of mistakes. Especially in urban traffic, where red lights are short, there's no need to bother. I've been driving for years without shifting to neutral and feel more at ease and efficient.

From a transmission perspective, shifting to neutral at red lights is not recommended. Automatic transmissions have torque converters and hydraulic systems that operate at optimal load when idling in Drive (D). Shifting to neutral causes unnecessary wear on components from idle spinning. Frequent gear changes increase fatigue on gears and bearings, especially in older models which are more prone to issues. Modern designs optimize fuel efficiency, but for long-term durability, simpler operation is better. I've encountered repair cases where excessive shifting caused failures. Therefore, keeping it in D while braking is the sensible choice - it avoids unnecessary trouble and preserves mechanical health.

I drive an automatic transmission car to and from work in the city, and I always get used to just stepping on the brake without shifting gears at red lights. City red lights are often very short, and shifting to neutral is a waste of energy with no real benefit. Once I tried shifting to neutral but forgot to shift back, resulting in a slow start and being honked at by the car behind me—very embarrassing. Keeping it in D gear is smoother and more worry-free, and it also adapts to different light durations. If I feel tired from stopping for too long, I might shift to neutral for a short break, but that's rare. Driving is all about pragmatism, and modern technology has simplified everything. From experience, fewer operations mean more relaxation and efficiency, so I recommend trying this method. It saves fuel and avoids unnecessary hassle—why not? Driving shouldn’t be complicated.


