···
Log in / Register

Should You Shift to Neutral at Traffic Lights in an Automatic Transmission Car?

5 Answers
Genesis
07/23/25 10:39pm

Shifting to neutral at traffic lights is the correct approach for automatic transmission cars, and using the handbrake in conjunction enhances safety. Engaging N (Neutral) gear with the handbrake applied can be more fuel-efficient, as the passive wheel in the torque converter of the transmission remains in an idling state, not adding extra load to the engine, which naturally reduces fuel consumption. More detailed information is as follows: 1. Waiting at traffic lights in D (Drive) gear with the foot brake pressed means the passive wheel in the torque converter between the engine and transmission is fixed, creating a counterforce on the driving wheel, thereby increasing the engine's load. This can be understood as hindering the engine's operation. Consequently, the engine's ECU increases fuel injection, leading to higher fuel consumption, which is why you can observe a high instantaneous fuel consumption when the car is stopped. 2. It is not recommended to wait at traffic lights in P (Park) gear because shifting from P to D can sometimes cause the car to reverse, affecting the vehicle behind and potentially leading to a rear-end collision, for which you may also bear some responsibility. 3. Some vehicles now come equipped with an 'autohold' function, which is an automatic handbrake. After activating this function with a button press, the vehicle automatically applies the brakes once stopped, eliminating the need to shift from reverse or drive gears, keeping the vehicle in a parked state. However, not shifting into neutral still poses certain safety risks, such as the vehicle lurching forward if the accelerator is mistakenly pressed, increasing the chance of a collision. Additionally, the auto start-stop function is also suitable for use at traffic lights, helping to save fuel to some extent, and the engine, when turned off, does not emit exhaust fumes into the car.

Was this review help?
17
5
Share
Daryl
08/10/25 6:24pm

I usually drive an automatic transmission car and don't shift to neutral at red lights. Modern car designs are quite intelligent - just keeping it in D gear while braking is sufficient. This allows the engine to enter an efficient idle state, and the auto start-stop system will activate to reduce fuel consumption. Frequently switching to neutral actually wastes fuel because the engine idles without doing actual work. From an environmental perspective, fewer gear shifts benefit emission reduction. I've also noticed that braking in D gear illuminates the brake lights, alerting following vehicles. Unless the red light lasts over a minute, like at some long intersections, there's no need to bother. Overall, shifting to neutral offers few benefits while adding driving burden and affecting acceleration. I recommend developing the D gear habit - it's simple and practical.

Was this review help?
10
5
Share
Expand All
OLeonardo
09/23/25 6:41am

As a frequent driver, I believe shifting to neutral at red lights is not very safe. Keeping the car in D gear with the brake pressed ensures the vehicle is ready to respond immediately, avoiding potential rolling risks. Automatic transmissions are designed to simplify operations, and unnecessary gear shifts can easily distract attention. In case of a rear-end collision, being in D gear provides some cushioning protection. I've also noticed that the brake lights stay on when the brake is pressed, increasing visibility and reducing the chance of a rear-end collision. In the long run, safe driving habits are key; shifting to neutral offers no additional advantages and may instead increase the likelihood of mistakes. Especially in urban traffic, where red lights are short, there's no need to bother. I've been driving for years without shifting to neutral and feel more at ease and efficient.

Was this review help?
19
5
Share
Expand All
McGeorge
11/07/25 2:08am

From a transmission perspective, shifting to neutral at red lights is not recommended. Automatic transmissions have torque converters and hydraulic systems that operate at optimal load when idling in Drive (D). Shifting to neutral causes unnecessary wear on components from idle spinning. Frequent gear changes increase fatigue on gears and bearings, especially in older models which are more prone to issues. Modern designs optimize fuel efficiency, but for long-term durability, simpler operation is better. I've encountered repair cases where excessive shifting caused failures. Therefore, keeping it in D while braking is the sensible choice - it avoids unnecessary trouble and preserves mechanical health.

Was this review help?
5
4
Share
Expand All
MacBrooke
12/28/25 3:53am

I drive an automatic transmission car to and from work in the city, and I always get used to just stepping on the brake without shifting gears at red lights. City red lights are often very short, and shifting to neutral is a waste of energy with no real benefit. Once I tried shifting to neutral but forgot to shift back, resulting in a slow start and being honked at by the car behind me—very embarrassing. Keeping it in D gear is smoother and more worry-free, and it also adapts to different light durations. If I feel tired from stopping for too long, I might shift to neutral for a short break, but that's rare. Driving is all about pragmatism, and modern technology has simplified everything. From experience, fewer operations mean more relaxation and efficiency, so I recommend trying this method. It saves fuel and avoids unnecessary hassle—why not? Driving shouldn’t be complicated.

Was this review help?
14
0
Share
Expand All
More Forum Discussions

Which Binyue model has a four-cylinder engine?

Binyue 1.4T is equipped with a four-cylinder engine. Here are some extended details: 1. Two models of Binyue 1.4T: They are the Manual Shooter and DCT Hunter. Apart from the different transmissions—matched with a 6-speed manual and 6-speed dual-clutch transmission respectively—the main difference lies in the configuration, with the latter being slightly more abundant. 2. Differences between the Manual Shooter and DCT Hunter: The DCT Hunter comes with additional features such as driving mode selection (sport, economy, and comfort modes), auto hold, electric sunroof, keyless entry, GPS navigation, voice recognition (for multimedia, navigation, and phone control), and car networking. In terms of convenience, the automatic transmission model performs better. If you have decent driving skills, the Manual Shooter is sufficient for family use. As an entry-level model, it mainly exists to lower the price, and pre-ordering is required for purchase.
13
5
Share

How to Call for Rescue When a Motorcycle Breaks Down?

If the repair shop is relatively close, you can push the motorcycle to the repair shop or ask the repair shop technician to come and help with the repairs. If the distance is far, it can be a bit difficult. You can call 114 to inquire about the nearest repair shop and contact them to see if a technician can come to help with the repairs or if additional fees are required for the service. Otherwise, you can only seek assistance from the police. Below is additional information: Break-in period oil: The break-in period for a motorcycle is 1500 km to 2000 km. You can change the oil at intervals of 200 km, 500 km, 800 km, 1500 km, and 2000 km. During the break-in period of a new motorcycle, the meshing of gears, the operation of pushrods or chains in the engine will produce iron debris, so it is advisable to change the oil frequently. Be sure to go to an authorized service center to use specialized oil and avoid opting for cheaper oil alternatives.
6
2
Share

Can the Sagitar use 92-octane gasoline?

No. According to the official vehicle manual recommendation, the Sagitar should use 95-octane gasoline. In addition to checking the suitable gasoline grade in the vehicle manual, you can also find it on the fuel tank cap, which will be clearly marked. Generally, the gasoline grade can also be determined based on the engine's compression ratio. Vehicles with an engine compression ratio between 8.6-9.9 should use 92-octane gasoline, while those with a compression ratio between 10.0-11.5 should use 95-octane gasoline. However, with the application of some new technologies, the gasoline grade cannot be solely determined by the compression ratio. A high compression ratio can also be adjusted to use lower-octane gasoline because, besides the compression ratio, other factors such as ignition timing, turbocharging technology, and Atkinson cycle technology also play a role. Generally, the higher the gasoline grade, the higher the octane number and the better the anti-knock performance. 92-octane gasoline contains 92% isooctane and 8% n-heptane, while 95-octane gasoline contains 95% isooctane and 5% n-heptane. If you accidentally use the wrong gasoline grade for the Sagitar, simply switch back to the correct grade after using it up. However, long-term use of the wrong gasoline grade can have the following effects: For vehicles recommended to use lower-octane gasoline, using higher-octane gasoline will not cause damage, but the increase in octane number will change the fuel's ignition point, leading to delayed combustion in the engine. This means both the engine's power output and thermal efficiency will decrease, resulting in poorer performance in practice. For vehicles recommended to use higher-octane gasoline, using lower-octane gasoline can cause engine knocking. Because the octane number is too low, the gasoline's ignition point decreases and may ignite prematurely during the compression stroke. If the fuel ignites before the spark plug fires during the compression stroke, resistance will occur during the upward stroke. This resistance makes the engine run very unstably. If the knocking is imperceptible, it only increases noise and does not significantly damage the engine. However, if the knocking is noticeable, it indicates severe engine conditions. The vibration not only affects driving stability but can also cause abnormal wear on the pistons and cylinders, and in severe cases, cylinder scoring.
6
3
Share

How to Deal with Clogged Car Air Conditioning Pipes?

Turn off the power, use a Phillips screwdriver to open the front panel and partition, exposing the condenser and drainage tray. Fill a mineral water bottle with water and flush the drainage pipe along the tray, repeating several times to see if it can be unclogged. If not, use a thin wire to slowly unclog it, remove the blockage, and then rinse with water until the drainage is smooth. Reinstall the partition and panel in the reverse order of removal. Here is additional information: Air conditioning drainage outlet: The air conditioning drainage hole is located under the chassis, and its exact position varies by car model. The car air conditioning produces condensed water during the cooling process, and the condensed water pipe is located under the chassis. During the rainy season, passing through mud and stagnant water can also lead to clogging of the drainage hole, with consequences similar to those of a clogged engine compartment drainage hole—water may flow back into the car, causing water accumulation on the floor. Cleaning method: Crawl under the chassis and use a thin wire to handle it; the unclogging process is relatively simple.
15
4
Share

What are the differences between the Volkswagen Lavida Plus and the Verano?

The differences between the Volkswagen Lavida Plus and the Verano are: 1. Different transmissions: The Volkswagen Lavida Plus has a 5-speed manual transmission, while the Verano has a 6-speed automatic transmission with manual mode. 2. Different rear suspension types: The Volkswagen Lavida Plus has a torsion beam non-independent suspension, while the Verano has a torsion beam with Watt's linkage non-independent suspension. More details are as follows: 1. Volkswagen Lavida Plus: The Volkswagen Lavida Plus is a compact car released by SAIC Volkswagen Group. Its front design resembles the Arteon, with horizontal grilles integrated with the headlights and a chrome strip running across the top of the grille. The headlights are more refined. 2. Verano: The Verano is the flagship model in Buick's compact car lineup. Its exterior adopts the new family-style design language, featuring a bold front face and dynamic, flowing body lines.
7
0
Share

What is the actual fuel consumption of the Haval H6?

Among the three models of Haval H6, the H6 Sport version has a combined fuel consumption of 6.6L/100km, which is at a leading level. Meanwhile, both the new Haval H6 and Haval H6 Coupe are equipped with the "Double Top Ten" powertrain combination, consisting of China's Top Ten Engines and the World's Top Ten Transmissions, achieving a combined fuel consumption of 6.8L/100km. Below are more related tips: 1. Avoid prolonged idling or low-speed driving: When waiting for someone by the roadside or temporarily parking, if the vehicle idles in place, the engine is still running, causing a significant increase in fuel consumption per 100 kilometers. Moreover, under such stagnant or low-speed conditions, due to the relatively low engine speed, combustion in the engine cylinders is incomplete, leading to carbon buildup, which further increases fuel consumption. Therefore, avoiding prolonged idling and low-speed driving is crucial for reducing fuel consumption. 2. Avoid excessive vehicle load and a full fuel tank: The more weight the vehicle carries, the higher the fuel consumption during driving. Many owners treat their cars as mobile storage spaces, stuffing them with various items. Over time, the vehicle's load becomes significantly "overweight," resulting in higher fuel consumption compared to owners who keep their cars clean and free of excessive clutter. Additionally, when refueling, it's not necessary to fill the tank completely; adding only half a tank can also reduce the vehicle's weight. 3. Avoid using high-viscosity engine oil: Owners should be aware that under the same environmental conditions, using engine oils with different viscosities will result in different fuel consumption levels. If a higher viscosity oil than recommended in the maintenance manual is used, the vehicle's fuel consumption will also change. 4. Use the accelerator to control speed rather than the brake: When driving, avoid sudden acceleration and hard braking. On open and smooth roads, try to maintain a constant speed, as the vehicle's fuel consumption is lowest at around 80 km/h. In congested traffic, anticipate the distance to the vehicle ahead and lightly press the accelerator, controlling speed through throttle adjustments rather than braking. While braking itself doesn't consume fuel, restarting the vehicle from a complete stop is quite fuel-intensive. Additionally, activating the engine start-stop function on the H6 can help avoid burning unnecessary fuel while waiting at red lights.
13
4
Share
Cookie
Cookie Settings
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.