How to choose between GLE and X5?
3 Answers
Both brands have distinct styles, but BMW has now caught up in terms of quality and details, especially with some of the interior finishing touches, surpassing Mercedes-Benz. The Mercedes-Benz GLE stands out with its exterior design, power, and lighting, which are the most satisfying aspects. The air suspension and transmission also enhance the driving experience. The BMW X5 has reached an unprecedented level in technical equipment and performance among four-wheel-drive vehicles. It boasts excellent handling sensitivity and stability.
I also considered the GLE and X5 before, and the choice really depends on daily habits. The GLE offers a more comfortable ride with softer seats, making long trips less tiring. It has ample rear space, which is convenient for installing child seats. On the other hand, the BMW X5's sport suspension is stiffer, with noticeable vibrations on bumpy roads, making it more suitable for those who enjoy a sense of control. In terms of interior, the GLE exudes a stronger premium feel with solid materials and excellent sound insulation, ensuring undisturbed music listening or conversations. The X5, however, has quicker steering response and more direct acceleration, delivering driving fun, though its chassis tuning often leads to passenger complaints about the bumpy ride. Additionally, considering practicality, the GLE has a larger trunk capacity, while the BMW offers a lower loading height. Both models are well-equipped with safety features like automatic braking and blind-spot monitoring. Price-wise, the GLE is slightly more expensive, but Mercedes offers a longer warranty period. Though maintenance costs are higher, its long-term resale value remains stable. Overall, if you frequently travel with family or prioritize comfort, the GLE is the better fit. If you're single or enjoy spirited driving, the X5 is more your match.
I've test-driven the GLE and X5 several times, and the performance differences are quite pronounced. The X5's powertrain responds quickly, especially in Sport mode, delivering strong acceleration with a noticeable push-back feeling, precise steering, and stable cornering control—it feels like playing a racing game. The GLE's engine is smooth and quiet, with linear power delivery, making it easy to drive and suitable for stop-and-go traffic or highway cruising, but it lacks excitement. In terms of fuel consumption, the X5's mild hybrid version is more economical, especially in city driving, while the GLE's V8 version, though powerful, is more expensive to fuel. Regarding transmissions, BMW's 8-speed gearbox is silky smooth, while Mercedes' 9-speed shifts seamlessly. In handling, the X5's shorter wheelbase makes it more agile in turns, whereas the GLE's steering feels slightly heavier. Suspension is a key point: the X5's firmer setup provides strong road feedback but compromises comfort, while the GLE's softer suspension minimizes bumps. If you prioritize driving excitement, the X5 is the clear choice—it's packed with fun. For stability and comfort, the GLE is the safer bet.
