
The cost to insure a car is generally lower than the average for all vehicles, but the final premium depends heavily on the specific model, your location, and your driving history. On average, you can expect to pay between $1,400 and $1,800 per year for full coverage. Smaller, older models like the Fortwo tend to be cheaper to insure, while newer, higher-performance electric models like the #1 or the upcoming #3 will command higher premiums due to their advanced technology and higher repair costs.
Several key factors determine your insurance rate:
The table below provides estimated annual full-coverage insurance costs for popular smart car models, based on a 40-year-old driver with a clean record.
| Smart Car Model | Average Annual Insurance Cost (Full Coverage) | Key Cost Influencer |
|---|---|---|
| Smart Fortwo (2018) | ~$1,450 | Low purchase price, good safety |
| Smart EQ Fortwo (2021) | ~$1,550 | Higher tech components, battery risk |
| Smart #1 (2023) | ~$1,750+ | New model, high-tech features, higher value |
| Smart Forfour (2018) | ~$1,500 | Slightly larger, similar parts cost to Fortwo |
The most effective way to get an accurate price is to get quotes from multiple insurers. Be sure to ask about discounts for safety features, bundling policies, and good driving records.

I was surprised when I got my EQ Fortwo. I figured such a tiny thing would be dirt-cheap to insure. It is cheaper than my old SUV, but not by a huge margin. The agent told me that while it's safe, the specialized electric parts and sensors can be pricey to fix after a fender bender. My advice? Don't just assume it'll be the cheapest option; get a few quotes specific to the exact model you're looking at. It only takes a few minutes online.

From an perspective, smart cars present a mixed bag. Their small size and excellent urban safety ratings work in their favor, potentially lowering liability and collision risk premiums. However, this is often offset by higher-than-expected repair costs. Many body panels and advanced tech components are unique and expensive. For newer electric models, the high-voltage battery pack is a significant factor insurers consider. The final cost is a calculation of these competing risk factors against your personal driver profile.

My friend bought a used Fortwo specifically to save money, and insurance was a big part of that calculation. He compared rates for a few days and found that his premium was about 15% less than what he paid for his previous sedan. He made a point to tell the insurance company about all the standard safety features, which seemed to help. His takeaway was that for the older gas models, the savings are real, but you have to shop around to find the best deal.

If you're considering a car, think about the total cost of ownership, not just the sticker price. Insurance is a part of that. Generally, you'll pay less than for a typical family car, but don't expect a tiny premium. Newer, tech-heavy models will cost more to cover. The best move is to contact your insurance agent before you buy. Give them the specific Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) of the car you're considering for a precise quote. This prevents any surprises after you've already signed the paperwork.


