Does crossing the stop line during a yellow light count as running a red light?

[StAdam]

According to the "Regulations for the Implementation of the Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China," vehicles that have already crossed the stop line when the yellow light is flashing at an intersection may continue to proceed. If the yellow light is already on and you continue to force your way through, being caught by the camera will still count as running a red light. According to the relevant provisions in the "Procedures for Handling Road Traffic Violations," motor vehicle drivers who violate traffic signal lights at intersections will be penalized with 6 demerit points. Additionally, in accordance with the relevant provisions of the "Road Traffic Safety Law," a fine may also be imposed. Criteria for determining running a red light: Electronic eyes capture three photos as the basis for determining a red-light violation: the front wheels crossing the stop line, the rear wheels crossing the stop line, and the front wheels crossing the opposite stop line. Only when all three photos are present will it be considered running a red light. When the red light is on, if you cross the stop line but manage to stop the vehicle even if you have already crossed the line, it will not be considered running a red light. However, it will be considered stopping beyond the line, which, according to traffic laws, is categorized as failing to drive or stop as required at intersections, resulting in a penalty of 3 demerit points. How to avoid running a red light while driving: Follow the arrow signal if there is one; otherwise, follow the circular light. When the red light is on, the front of the vehicle must not cross the stop line. When the yellow light is on, the front of the vehicle must not cross the stop line. When the green light just starts flashing, if you are close and moving fast, you should proceed because you might not be able to stop in time and could cross the stop line. If you are far away, moving slowly, or the intersection is congested, you should stop. When driving in the city, develop the habit of looking for traffic lights whenever you see a crosswalk or stop line and approach an intersection.

[OAndrew]

As an experienced ordinary driver, I often encounter yellow lights at intersections. Based on my experience, if your entire vehicle has already crossed the stop line the moment the yellow light comes on, it generally doesn't count as running a red light. But if you're still behind the line and step on the accelerator to rush through when seeing the yellow light, it's likely a violation. The rules may vary slightly in different regions, but essentially, yellow lights are designed to remind drivers to slow down and stop, not to accelerate. I remember once being caught by a camera when rushing through a yellow light, and the fine was a painful lesson. Actually, safety comes first: when the yellow light comes on, I quickly judge based on speed and distance—if there's still space to stop steadily, I brake immediately; if it's too close and braking would cause skidding, I gently press the accelerator and pass carefully. Avoiding rear-end collisions or crashes is key—better to stop for three seconds than rush for one. This habit keeps my driving safe and worry-free.

[Miller]

From the perspective of ensuring safe driving, I believe the issue of crossing the stop line when the yellow light comes on must be clearly addressed. If your vehicle has already crossed the line before the yellow light appears, it does not count as running a red light; however, forcing your way through afterward may constitute a violation and pose risks. I know many accidents stem from this, such as rear-end collisions or pedestrian impacts caused by drivers rushing through the light. Therefore, my principle is to immediately slow down and assess the situation when the yellow light appears—stopping if possible, and proceeding only if the position is critical. Developing this defensive driving habit can reduce fines and injuries, protecting everyone's safety. Remember, traffic signal rules exist for order; rushing through a light may save a few seconds, but the consequences can be severe. Safety should always come first.

[MacAriel]

I just started driving not long ago, and I often hesitate when the yellow light comes on. The instructor taught me that if you've already crossed the stop line the moment the yellow light turns on, it's not considered illegal; but if you're still starting and cross the line, you might get fined. Now I've learned to be smarter: as soon as I see the yellow light, I slow down and prepare to stop, unless the front of the car is right at the stop line, then I cautiously proceed. This way, I drive with much more peace of mind, avoiding fines and preventing accidents. From a novice to an experienced driver, it's a step-by-step process—safety is more important than speed.