Do I Need to Press the Clutch When Braking in Second Gear?

[SanBrantley]

Whether to press the clutch when braking in second gear depends on how much speed you need to reduce. If the speed reduction is minimal, there's no need to press the clutch. However, if you need to significantly reduce speed without stopping, you should press the clutch first before braking. Here are a few scenarios: When the speed reduction is slight, such as decreasing from 70 km/h to 65 km/h, you can directly apply the brake without pressing the clutch. When you need to significantly reduce speed without stopping—for example, if you're in 5th gear at 70 km/h and need to slow down to 10 km/h—failing to press the clutch and applying heavy brakes will cause the vehicle to start shaking once the speed drops below a certain point (e.g., under 30 km/h). If the speed drops further or the vehicle stops, it may stall. In such cases, you should press the clutch first and then apply the brakes. The role of the clutch: The clutch allows the driving force of the car to increase gradually, enabling smooth starts. It temporarily separates the engine from the transmission for gear shifting, prevents overload in the drivetrain, and reduces torsional vibration impacts from the engine, thereby extending the lifespan of the transmission gears.

[DanielaLynn]

When dealing with the clutch issue while braking in second gear, I make decisions based on the current speed and situation. If it's a gentle brake on a flat road and the car can still run smoothly, I might not press the clutch to save some effort. However, if the speed drops too low—like when almost stopping—the engine might stall due to low RPM, so once I increase brake pressure or feel the car shaking, I immediately press the clutch to avoid trouble. During emergency braking, I must press the clutch simultaneously to prevent stalling and loss of control, especially in rainy conditions or on curves. The same applies when stopping: brake first to slow down, then press the clutch and shift to neutral for safety. Overall, I adjust flexibly based on road conditions, prioritizing safety.

[Harry]

For whether to press the clutch when braking in second gear, my usual approach is to first assess the vehicle speed and degree of deceleration. When the speed is relatively high, lightly applying the brakes without pressing the clutch allows the engine to assist in deceleration, which can also save some fuel. However, if the speed drops sharply or during frequent starts and stops, such as in city traffic jams, I press the clutch to prevent stalling and reduce wear. From a vehicle maintenance perspective, consistently not pressing the clutch at low speeds can accelerate clutch disc wear, leading to troublesome repairs over time. It's advisable for novice drivers to develop the habit of pressing the clutch—simple and reliable, not cutting corners for convenience. The key is to practice sensing RPM changes and finding the right timing.

[MadelineAnn]

When learning to drive, the instructor taught me to always press the clutch when braking in second gear. This is because the speed drops quickly in second gear, and if the RPM gets too low, the engine can stall easily, which may lead to accidents. When I first started driving, I made a few mistakes because I forgot to press the clutch while braking, causing the engine to stop. This is especially important to remember on slopes—always press the clutch. Now I follow this principle: if the deceleration is noticeable, press the clutch—safety first. With more daily practice, it becomes second nature and very practical.