···
Log in / Register

can you use an rtg in an electric car

3 Answers
LaCatherine
12/21/25 8:16pm

No, you cannot use a Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generator (RTG) in a consumer electric car. RTGs are nuclear power sources that convert heat from the decay of radioactive materials, like plutonium-238, directly into electricity. While they offer incredible longevity and are impervious to weather, their application is strictly limited to deep-space probes (like the Voyager spacecraft), remote lighthouses, or polar research stations due to profound safety, legal, and practical barriers for automotive use.

The primary reason is safety. An RTG contains highly radioactive material. Any car accident could potentially lead to a catastrophic release of radiation, posing an extreme public health risk. The shielding required to make it safe would be incredibly heavy, defeating the purpose of a lightweight, efficient vehicle. Furthermore, the legal and regulatory hurdles are insurmountable; public road use of such a device would be banned by numerous national and international nuclear regulatory bodies.

From a practical standpoint, RTGs are also a poor fit. They are not designed for the dynamic power demands of a car, which requires rapid acceleration and high peak power. RTGs provide a constant, relatively low power output, more suited to trickle-charging a battery than propelling a vehicle directly. They are also astronomically expensive to build and fuel compared to lithium-ion battery packs.

AspectRTG (Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generator)Standard EV Battery Pack
Power SourceDecay of radioactive isotopes (e.g., Plutonium-238)Electrochemical reaction (Lithium-ion)
Primary UseSpacecraft, remote scientific stationsConsumer vehicles, electronics
Safety ProfileExtreme radiation hazard in case of breachThermal runaway fire risk in case of damage
Power OutputLow, constant trickle of powerHigh, can deliver massive power bursts for acceleration
EfficiencyVery low (around 5-7% thermal to electric)High (around 80-90% round-trip efficiency)
LifespanExtremely long (decades)8-15 years before significant degradation
CostExtremely high (millions of dollars per unit)Decreasing cost (thousands of dollars)
Regulatory StatusHeavily restricted, not for public useApproved and regulated for consumer use

In summary, while the concept of a "nuclear battery" is fascinating, the technology is completely inappropriate and illegal for passenger vehicles. The automotive industry's focus is rightly on improving the safety, energy density, and affordability of conventional battery technology.

Was this review help?
10
0
Share
EllaMarie
12/30/25 12:06am

As a guy who loves tinkering with car tech, the idea is cool but a total non-starter. Think about it: you'd be driving around with a mini nuclear reactor. A fender bender could turn into a major hazmat situation. The government would never allow it, and the cost would be insane. We're better off hoping for solid-state batteries to give us that long-range boost we all want. Stick to the charging stations; it's way simpler.

Was this review help?
5
2
Share
Expand All
MacNoah
01/06/26 8:49am

From an engineering perspective, the fundamental mismatch is in power density and dynamic response. An RTG provides steady, low-level power for decades, perfect for a satellite. An electric car needs to draw hundreds of kilowatts instantly for acceleration and then regenerate power back under braking. An RTG cannot do this. It's a brilliant solution for the wrong problem. The vehicle would be dangerously underpowered and heavy, making it impractical for any real-world driving scenario.

Was this review help?
10
0
Share
Expand All
More Forum Discussions

What are the three major warning signs of brake failure?

Signs of brake failure include brake pedal vibration and brakes not returning to position. The details are as follows: Brake pedal vibration: If you feel the brake pedal vibrating when braking at high speeds on the highway, it may indicate uneven surface wear on the brake discs. Brakes not returning to position: Loss of elasticity in the brakes often involves damage to multiple components. Brake misalignment: If the brakes shift when applied, it indicates uneven force distribution between the left and right brake calipers, requiring immediate repair. Reduced braking effectiveness: This condition, known as "soft brakes," occurs when braking force diminishes due to insufficient hydraulic pressure in the wheel cylinders or master cylinder, often accompanied by oil leakage.
16
1
Share

Why is the driving range increasing?

The possible reasons for the increase in driving range are reduced fuel consumption or a malfunctioning fuel tank sensor. The specific reasons are as follows: Actual fuel consumption reduction: The driving range displayed on the dashboard is calculated by the vehicle's computer based on the amount of fuel remaining. If the vehicle's fuel consumption decreases on certain road sections, it can lead to an increase in the driving range. Fuel tank sensor malfunction: The driving range is determined by the amount of fuel remaining, and the fuel gauge is based on the fuel level sensor. Therefore, the conclusion is that the driving range depends on the fuel level sensor. The fuel level sensor is installed inside the fuel tank and detects the amount of fuel based on the fuel level. The fuel level sensor is commonly referred to as the fuel float. If the fuel float malfunctions, it may cause the driving range to increase.
17
5
Share

How Many Winters Can Winter Tires Be Used?

Winter tires can be used for 3-4 winters. The service life of winter tires is 3-4 years, or 50,000-60,000 kilometers. Winter tires have good drainage: In terms of appearance, unlike regular or unidirectional tires, winter tires have asymmetric directional tread patterns. Winter tires have more grooves, meaning the proportion of grooves on the tire surface is higher, which improves drainage. Winter tires have at least 1,000 fine grooves, while regular tires have about 200. Winter tires improve safety: Winter tires are softer in material compared to regular tires, mainly because the tread uses some special formulations, such as a silica-mixed rubber compound that can adhere more closely to smooth ice surfaces, generating greater friction than all-season tires. This significantly enhances the vehicle's handling and safety on slippery ice surfaces.
16
0
Share

Is 93 gasoline the same as the current 92 gasoline?

92 gasoline is the same as the previous 93 gasoline; they are the same type of fuel. Gasoline classification: Currently, in the domestic market, gasoline is labeled with numbers such as 90, 93, 95, and 97. These numbers represent the octane rating of the gasoline, which indicates its anti-knock performance and has nothing to do with the cleanliness of the fuel. How to choose gasoline: It is more scientific and economical to refuel according to the engine's compression ratio or the requirements specified in the car's manual, as this maximizes the engine's efficiency. The main basis for selecting the gasoline grade is the engine's compression ratio. Blindly using higher-grade gasoline not only results in sluggish acceleration but also fails to utilize its high anti-knock performance advantage, leading to unnecessary financial waste.
2
0
Share

How Long Does It Take for a Dual-Clutch Transmission to Overheat in Traffic?

How long it takes for a dual-clutch transmission to overheat in traffic mainly depends on the frequency of gear shifts and the vehicle speed. The more frequent the gear shifts and the slower the speed, the more likely it is to overheat. By paying attention to driving habits and avoiding frequent semi-engagement of the clutch, overheating can generally be prevented. Definition of Dual-Clutch Transmission: A Dual-Clutch Transmission (DCT) differs from conventional automatic transmission systems. It is based on a manual transmission but functions as an automatic transmission, combining the flexibility of a manual transmission with the comfort of an automatic transmission while providing uninterrupted power output. Advantages of Dual-Clutch Transmission: The gear shift time of a dual-clutch transmission is extremely short, even faster than that of a manual transmission, taking less than 0.2 seconds. Because it eliminates torque interruption, the engine's power is continuously utilized and always operates at its optimal performance, resulting in significant fuel savings. Compared to traditional planetary gear automatic transmissions, it is more conducive to improving fuel economy, reducing fuel consumption by approximately 15%.
14
0
Share

Is Vehicle Inspection Closed During National Day Holiday?

Most vehicle inspection institutions will be closed during the National Day holiday, but some regions may remain open. It is recommended to call and inquire. Definition of Vehicle Inspection: Vehicle inspection refers to a mandatory test for every car that has obtained an official license plate and registration certificate. It is equivalent to an annual physical examination for the vehicle in accordance with the "Technical Conditions for Motor Vehicle Operation Safety," aimed at promptly eliminating potential safety hazards and encouraging enhanced vehicle maintenance. Inspection Cycle: For passenger transport vehicles, inspections are required once a year within the first 5 years; once every 6 months after 5 years; and once every 6 months after 10 years. For small and micro non-operational passenger vehicles, inspections are required once every 2 years within the first 6 years; once a year after 6 years; and once every 6 months after 15 years.
9
0
Share
Cookie
Cookie Settings
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.