Yes, you can rent a car on Martha's Vineyard, and for many visitors, it's the most convenient way to explore the island's diverse towns and secluded beaches, especially if you're staying for more than a few days or traveling with family and gear. However, due to the island's limited size and infrastructure, planning ahead is absolutely critical. During the peak summer season (June through August), rental cars can sell out months in advance, and prices are at their highest.
Key Rental Companies and Contacts
| Rental Company | Primary Location(s) | Contact Method | Vehicle Type Focus |
|---|
| A-A Island Auto Rental | Vineyard Haven, Edgartown | Phone/Online | Sedans, SUVs, Wagons |
| Adventure Rental Co. | Oak Bluffs | Online/In-person | Jeeps, Convertibles |
| Vineyard Transport | Edgartown | Phone | Luxury Sedans, SUVs |
| Island Car Rentals | Vineyard Haven | Online | Economy Cars, Minivans |
| Martha's Vineyard Rentals | Airport, Oak Bluffs | Online/Phone | Standard Fleet, Vans |
The main rental agencies are located in the down-island towns of Vineyard Haven and Oak Bluffs, as well as at the Martha's Vineyard Airport (MVY). Some companies offer pick-up and drop-off services at the ferry terminals. It's wise to book your rental car as soon as your travel dates are confirmed. When comparing prices, be sure to factor in taxes and fees, and understand the company's fuel policy.
While a car offers flexibility, it's not the only option. The island has a reliable and affordable public bus system, the Vineyard Transit Authority (VTA), which services all major towns. For shorter trips within a single town, taxis and ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft are available, though they can be expensive and less reliable during peak times. For many day-trippers or those staying in a walkable area like Oak Bluffs, renting a bicycle or relying on the VTA can be a more relaxing and cost-effective choice, avoiding the hassle of finding parking, which can be challenging in the summer.
