
No, you generally cannot legally store a car without insurance if it’s registered, even if it’s not being driven. The rules vary significantly by state, but the major risk involves financial liability if the car is damaged or causes damage while in storage. The only way to legally suspend insurance is to officially suspend the vehicle's registration with your state's Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV).
Storing a car doesn't eliminate all risks. A comprehensive-only policy is the recommended solution. This is the portion of auto insurance that covers damage to your vehicle from non-collision events like theft, vandalism, fire, or a falling tree branch. It's typically very affordable when you remove liability, collision, and other coverages since you're not driving the car. This protects your financial investment in the vehicle itself.
If you simply cancel your insurance without suspending the registration, you face serious consequences. Most states have electronic verification systems, and your insurer is required to report the lapse in coverage. This can result in fines, driver's license suspension, and much higher insurance premiums when you eventually reinstate coverage. The table below outlines the primary options and their implications.
| Storage Action | Insurance Status | Registration Status | Key Risks & Consequences |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cancel Policy | No Insurance | Active | DMV fines, license suspension, high future premiums. Car is vulnerable to theft/vandalism with zero coverage. |
| Suspend Registration | No Insurance | Suspended | Legal, but car must be on private property. No protection for the car itself. Re-registering requires new fees and inspection. |
| Switch to Comprehensive-Only | Minimal Insurance | Active | The recommended approach. Legally complies with state reporting, protects car from physical damage at a low cost. |
| Maintain Full Policy | Full Insurance | Active | Most expensive option, unnecessary for long-term storage, but offers complete peace of mind. |
Before storing your car, contact your insurance agent to discuss switching to a comprehensive-only plan. Also, confirm the specific procedures with your local DMV for registration suspension if you choose that path. Proper preparation, like using a fuel stabilizer and storing the car in a secure, dry location, is just as important as the insurance decision.

Been there, done that. I learned the hard way after storing my old Mustang for the winter and canceling the insurance. The DMV sent a nasty fine because my registration was still active. My advice? Don't drop insurance entirely. Call your agent and ask for a "storage policy." It's basically just comprehensive coverage. It costs me next to nothing and means if some kid throws a rock through the window or a mouse chews the wires, I'm not paying for it all out of pocket. It’s cheap peace of mind.

Think of it from a legal standpoint first. State law usually requires continuous insurance for any vehicle with an active registration. If the DMV finds out your insurance lapsed, they will penalize you. The smart move is to maintain a minimal policy. You can remove liability and collision, keeping only comprehensive coverage. This satisfies legal requirements and protects your asset from fire or theft while it's parked. Always notify your insurer that the vehicle is in "storage" to get the proper rate.


