Can I proceed if I've already crossed the line when the left-turn signal turns red?
4 Answers
In this situation, you can proceed without it being considered a violation. Relevant laws and regulations: Article 38 of the "Regulations for the Implementation of the Road Traffic Safety Law" states: (1) When the green light is on, vehicles are permitted to pass, but turning vehicles must not hinder the passage of straight-going vehicles or pedestrians that have been given the right of way; when the yellow light is on, vehicles that have already crossed the stop line may continue to pass; when the red light is on, vehicles are prohibited from passing. Therefore, passing through an intersection or "dragging the tail" when the light is red is a violation. Qualified drivers should anticipate in advance and avoid "rushing the yellow light." Specific situations of running a red light: If captured by surveillance cameras, the party involved will be required to confirm the violation at the traffic police station, and points will be deducted from their license; if no one acknowledges the violation, the vehicle management office will prevent the vehicle from undergoing its annual inspection until the violation is resolved.
I remember encountering this situation while driving once. I was making a left turn at a large intersection, and the light turned red just after I passed the stop line. I wondered if I should continue. According to general traffic rules, if you have already entered the intersection before the signal turns red, you should safely complete the left turn to avoid sudden stops that could block traffic. However, after the light turns red, no new vehicles should enter, or it would be considered running a red light, which could result in fines or demerit points. The key is to observe the surroundings: ensure there are no oncoming straight-moving vehicles or pedestrians interfering—safety first. In fact, it’s best to anticipate signal changes and avoid rushing through yellow lights; slowing down early and paying attention to countdown signals is more reliable. This experience reminded me to stay focused while driving, as developing good habits can reduce the risk of accidents. Now, I always try to assess the situation clearly during the tail end of the green light before making a move.
After driving for a long time, I've also thought about this rule. Simply put, when the signal changes from yellow to red while you're making a left turn, if you've already crossed the stop line and entered the intersection, the law allows you to complete the turning maneuver, which is not considered a violation. This is because you're deemed to have safely proceeded at that point. However, starting or reversing after the light turns red is more dangerous and could cause accidents; you must yield to vehicles and pedestrians with the right of way from other directions. Personally, I recommend checking local traffic laws, as details may vary by province—some places, for instance, use cameras to record violations. As an additional note, installing a dashcam is very useful for proving your position at the time; also, avoid tailgating large vehicles, as they can block your view of signal changes. In short, safe driving is key: once you've crossed the line, proceed cautiously without hesitation or acceleration.
As a frequent driver, I understand your concern. Legally, once you've crossed the line when the light turns red, you should safely complete your left turn rather than stopping in the intersection creating hazards. But absolutely ensure the crossing is clear: pause or wait for the signal if approaching through traffic is spotted. Remember, red lights are mandatory stop commands that only apply to vehicles not yet in the intersection. From a safety perspective, prevention beats regret: watch signal countdowns, don't risk running yellows; practice defensive driving techniques like checking opposing lanes first.
