Share

Updated May 7, 2026, for U.S. readers
Two Ayrshire men are set to face a Scottish jury after denying charges that they used a knife and a knuckleduster during an alleged road-rage style confrontation in Kirkmichael. Jordan Goodwin, 28, and Allan Bolland, 45, both pleaded not guilty at Ayr Sheriff Court.
The case dates to Oct. 22, 2025. According to the Crown indictment, the two men behaved in a threatening and abusive manner toward a man and a woman at Boylston Crescent and outside Kirkmichael Primary School. The pair are accused of shouting and swearing at the couple, following them in a vehicle, blocking their car, and then repeatedly striking that vehicle, leaving visible damage. Prosecutors also say the men produced a knife and a knuckleduster and made offensive remarks during the incident.
Goodwin, from Whitehall Avenue in Patna, faces a charge of having a knife without lawful authority or reasonable excuse. Bolland, from Girvan Crescent in Newmilns, is charged with having a knuckleduster. Both men also face the same allegation of behaving in a threatening or abusive manner.
The separation of the weapons charges is normal in Scottish court practice. Knives and knuckledusters are treated differently in law, even when they are used together in a single alleged incident. A knife can be a lawful tool in some situations, so the Crown has to show the lack of a reasonable excuse or lawful authority. A knuckleduster, by contrast, is usually viewed as an offensive weapon made for physical combat, and carrying one in public is much harder to justify.
At a hearing at Ayr Sheriff Court, both accused entered formal not guilty pleas. The sheriff continued bail for both men, and the jury trial was added to the court diary for the early 2026 sitting.
Bail being continued is not a small detail. In Scotland, sheriffs can impose conditions such as no contact with complainants or no driving. The court did not spell out any specific conditions in the open court report. The important point for now is that neither man is in custody.
Because the Crown moved the case by indictment, it is being handled under solemn procedure. That is the more serious track in Scottish criminal justice, and it means a sheriff and jury will hear the evidence rather than a justice of the peace sitting alone.
The locations are likely to feature heavily in the evidence. Boylston Crescent is a residential street, and Kirkmichael Primary School is a public place. A jury may have to decide how visible the weapons were and whether the complainants had a clear view of them at the time. Witnesses who live nearby, or people connected with the school, could also be called to describe the couple’s reaction.
Vehicle damage could be another key piece of evidence. The Crown alleges the two men used a car to pursue the couple, cut off their route, and then strike their vehicle. That kind of allegation often leads to questions about who was driving, how fast the vehicles were moving, and whether the damage matches the claim.
The threatening-or-abusive-behaviour charge has a broad definition in Scots law. It covers words or conduct that would cause a reasonable person to suffer fear or alarm. It does not depend on the alleged victims being able to prove they were personally terrified. That matters here because the incident took place in a village street and outside a school, where other people could have observed the behaviour.
If the case reaches trial, 15 jurors will be sworn in. Unlike U.S. federal courts, which generally require unanimous verdicts, Scottish juries can convict by a majority of at least eight. That can be significant when the evidence involves a fast-moving chase and conflicting accounts of who did what.
The burden remains on the Crown throughout. Both Goodwin and Bolland are presumed innocent, and neither man has to give evidence unless he chooses to do so. The prosecution has to prove the charges beyond reasonable doubt.
A road-rage dispute that ends with accusations of weapons is familiar to many U.S. readers. In American jurisdictions, facts like these could translate into charges such as aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, brandishing, or criminal mischief. The Kirkmichael case is a useful comparison because the legal framework is noticeably different.
For U.S. audiences, the biggest takeaway is the role of “reasonable excuse” in Scottish weapons charges. A knife charge can fail if the defendant had a legitimate reason to carry the blade. But a knuckleduster is a different story — its sole practical purpose is to make a punch more damaging. That makes possession much harder to explain in court.
There is also an important difference in how the prosecution decides to charge. In Scotland, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service chooses the charges and selects the procedure. Here, the decision to proceed by indictment signals that prosecutors are treating the case as serious from an early stage.
Both men are expected back in court when the trial is called in the 2026 term. Unless there is a procedural hearing or a change of plea before then, the case will be heard by a sheriff and jury. A conviction on indictment could leave either man facing a custodial sentence, and the sheriff has broader sentencing powers under solemn procedure than in summary cases.
There has been no published verdict as of May 7, 2026. This article was rewritten on that date using the latest court report available. Trial dates in Ayrshire can shift, so any new hearing will be covered in a future update.
For now, the Kirkmichael pair remain on bail, and the case moves closer to what could be a lengthy jury trial. The charges are not unique, but the combination of knives, knuckledusters, and a car chase in a small Scottish village has made this one of the more closely watched local court cases of the legal term.









