Share

(June 7, 2025) — The governments of Baden-Württemberg, Bavaria and Lower Saxony — the German heartland of Mercedes-Benz, Porsche, BMW, Audi and Volkswagen — have jointly urged Brussels to make electric driving affordable, demanding lower public charging prices, a faster charging-network buildout, targeted support for used electric cars, and a more technology-neutral EU regulatory approach. The coordinated intervention lands as EU policymakers debate how to revive flagging EV sales ahead of the bloc's 2035 combustion-engine phase-out.
The three Länder don't often speak with one voice on transport policy. Bavaria is governed by the CSU, Baden-Württemberg by a center-right coalition, Lower Saxony by a Social Democrat-led government, and their automotive champions compete fiercely among themselves. That they now agree on a joint position paper signals how seriously the state governments view the EV transition.
The core argument of the paper is simple: the EU's climate targets are only credible if drivers actually want to buy electric cars. Right now, many don't. Between high purchase prices, patchy public charging and energy costs that make fast charging nearly as expensive as petrol, the states argue the bloc is turning its own climate ambitions into a political liability.
Charging economics sit at the heart of the complaint. Public DC fast charging in Germany typically runs between 55 and 79 euro cents per kWh, with peak prices at some highway stations approaching 90 cents or more. Home charging, particularly on a dedicated EV tariff, costs closer to 25 or 30 cents. The gap matters: drivers without a private wallbox — a majority of people in dense urban areas — are locked into the most expensive and least transparent way to charge.
The states want Brussels to treat electricity as a transport fuel and to harmonize price transparency rules across the EU, forcing operators to display price-per-kWh and any idle fees before a charging session begins. They also want tax treatment aligned, so that charging on the road doesn't cost more than charging at home. In several member states, VAT on public charging exceeds the reduced rate applied to household electricity — a distortion that no amount of infrastructure funding can fix.
There is a competitiveness angle too. Chinese fast-charging networks typically price electricity well below the European average, part of a broader industrial strategy that pairs affordable cars with affordable energy. European operators argue they are squeezed by grid fees, land costs and low utilization. The states reply that operators have had years to optimize, and that consolidation is making the market less competitive, not more.
Germany crossed the mark of roughly 120,000 public charging points in late 2024 and keeps adding capacity quickly, but quantity masks quality issues. A large share of the installed base is slow AC equipment; the high-power DC chargers that matter for long-distance travel remain concentrated along highways, leaving rural regions — where range anxiety runs highest — with thin coverage.
The three states want the EU to move beyond target-setting. They are asking the Commission to force member states to shorten grid-connection wait times, standardize permitting for charging hubs and use cohesion funds to fill commercial gaps in rural and semi-urban areas. They also want Europe-wide reliability standards; some driver surveys suggest that one in five charging attempts in the EU ends in failure due to broken hardware or software problems.
Under the Alternative Fuels Infrastructure Regulation (AFIR), in force since April 2024, the bloc requires fast-charging stations every 60 kilometers along core highway corridors. The states call this baseline "necessary but insufficient," particularly for heavy trucks, and want minimum power ratings per station raised in the next regulatory review.
Perhaps the most forward-looking part of the paper concerns second-hand cars. Used EV prices in Germany have fallen sharply over the past two years — by 30 to 40 percent in some cases — making older models suddenly accessible. But the market remains fragile: buyers cannot reliably assess battery health, and a failed battery pack can cost as much to replace as the car itself.
The states propose an EU-wide battery health certificate, standardized for every used EV sale, drawing on data from battery management systems. They also want Brussels to consider demand-side measures such as purchase incentives or reduced registration taxes on used EVs, and to oblige automakers to keep delivering software updates for older models.
The EU battery passport — set to become mandatory under the Battery Regulation in February 2027 — is an obvious vehicle for this. The states argue the Commission should accelerate its rollout and integrate it into second-hand sales, not just the industrial supply chain. Done right, this would give consumers the confidence to choose a cheap electric car over a cheap petrol one — and defend the residual values that make new EVs more affordable to lease in the first place.
The third pillar of the states' position is a rebuke to the Commission's near-single-minded focus on battery-electric vehicles. The EU's 2035 phase-out of new combustion-engine sales formally allows e-fuels, but the rules implement that exemption in ways that make it almost unusable in practice. The states want that rebalanced.
They argue that plug-in hybrids still have a role, that hydrogen makes sense for trucks, and that the EU should set carbon targets rather than technology mandates. This is familiar ground: Bavaria and Baden-Württemberg have long defended e-fuel and hybrid pathways, reflecting their automakers' deep engineering investment in internal combustion. Lower Saxony, the home of Volkswagen's aggressive EV push, has historically sided with Brussels. That it now signs on suggests economic headwinds have shifted its calculus.
The Commission's own turn on CO2 compliance points in the same direction. In May 2025, Brussels formally proposed letting automakers average their CO2 performance across 2025-2027 — a flexibility mechanism designed to prevent billions in fines while EV demand is flat. Critics call it a weakening of climate law; industry calls it realism. The states' paper endorses the second reading, and asks for comparable flexibility on the technology side.
The timing of the states' push is deliberate. The European Commission has pledged an action plan on e-mobility this year, with measures on charging infrastructure, grid capacity and demand stimulation. Most of its proposals, however, are non-binding, and the states want legally enforceable commitments.
There is a macroeconomic argument they can lean on. European automakers are losing share to Chinese competitors at home while watching export markets erode. ACEA figures show battery-electric vehicles holding roughly 13 to 15 percent of new EU car registrations in early 2025 — well behind China's penetration and barely better than a year ago. The states argue that the energy transition, the industrial transition and the jobs transition have to be managed as a single problem.
Charging investment is stalling just as it should accelerate. The IEA's Global EV Outlook 2025, released this spring, noted that global EV sales keep growing almost entirely on the strength of China, while European sales slipped in 2024. The states are effectively telling Brussels that the credibility of the 2035 target — and the jobs attached to the auto sector — now ride on getting charging economics right.
American readers may wonder why German state politics is relevant to the US market. The answer: Europe's regulatory choices shape the global EV supply chain. When the EU demands battery health certificates, it pushes standardization on global battery makers, many of which supply American automakers. When Germany's states succeed in pushing charging prices down, it raises the competitive bar for automakers' pricing strategies worldwide — including in the US, where public fast-charging prices remain a recurring consumer complaint.
The policy parallel is direct. Federal EV charging funding in the US — the $7.5 billion NEVI program — has been effectively frozen since early 2025, leaving states to improvise with their own programs. The German states' message, that infrastructure targets, price transparency and used-market support must move together, is one US state policymakers are increasingly repeating. On used cars, the US already offers a federal tax credit of up to $4,000 for qualifying used EVs — something the EU lacks. The three Länder now want Brussels to catch up.
Whether this push changes EU policy depends on the response in Berlin and Brussels. The federal government is weighing its own EV incentive plans, and the states' paper strengthens the hand of industry-friendly ministers who want a renewed subsidy regime. In Brussels, the immediate milestones are the implementation of the e-mobility action plan and the 2026 review of the CO2 standards regulation — a process the states intend to influence early.
None of this alters the 2035 phase-out target; all three state governments say they accept it. But the paper makes clear that the path matters, and that the states intend to be in the room when it is charted. Their core demand — make electric mobility cheap, practical and trustworthy enough that consumers choose it voluntarily — is the least ideological ask on the table. It is also, as the charging-price equation keeps reminding everyone, the hardest one to deliver.









