Share

A recent change to the operating hours for daytime parking rates in downtown Columbus has left workers and evening visitors fuming, with many now paying double for a single stay.
Starting in early February 2025, the city shifted the window for daytime parking tariffs from the previous 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. to a new 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. schedule. While the all-day fee at several city-owned garages dropped from $38.50 to $7.50 and short-term rates were also cut, the unintended consequence is hitting those who arrive before 8 a.m. or stay past 8 p.m.
“I get to work at 7:30 a.m. and pay for parking until 5 p.m., but now I’m charged the evening rate for the first half-hour and the day rate for the rest,” said a Columbus accountant who asked not to be named. “That’s $3.50 evening plus $7.50 day – an extra 47% on top of what I expected. It adds up to about $80 a month.”
The accountant, who uses the High Street long-stay garage, noted occupancy has plummeted. “Before the 2020 fee hikes that garage was packed. Now it’s maybe one-third full. The machines show daytime rates but won’t take cards – who carries that much cash anymore?”
Evening event-goers are equally frustrated. Shortly after the change took effect, Columbus residents took to social media to vent. One user complained about attending a two-hour show at the Short North garage. “We ended up paying $9.50 for two hours. There were lines of confused and annoyed people at every pay machine.”
Another commenter predicted broader fallout. “This will hit families, volunteers, and community groups that attend evening meetings and activities downtown. Most people go between 6:30 and 8:30 p.m. Moving the evening tariff from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. effectively raises costs during the most popular social hours. If the goal is to encourage downtown foot traffic, this seems counterproductive.”
The Columbus Downtown Development Authority confirmed that parking utilization data for February shows a 12% drop in early-morning entries compared to the same month last year, while evening entries between 6 p.m. and 8 p.m. fell by 8%. Local business owners near the garages also report a noticeable dip in dinner-time customers since the change.
“We’ve heard from at least five regulars who said they’re avoiding downtown events because parking now feels like a penalty,” said Maria Connelly, owner of a High Street bistro. “Evening ticket sales for our live music nights dropped 15% in March.”
City Councilor James Thorne, who chairs the transportation committee, acknowledged the backlash. “We understand the concerns. The daytime rate change was meant to simplify pricing and reduce costs for the majority of users, but we clearly didn’t anticipate the friction at the edges. A review of the tariff schedule will begin next month, and we will consider restoring the 6 a.m. start or introducing a grace period.”
Thorne added that the city is also exploring mobile-pay options and contactless payment at all garages, an upgrade long requested by commuters.
Parking expert Dr. Linda Harwood, a transportation policy researcher at Ohio State University, said the Columbus situation mirrors a common pitfall. “When cities adjust rate windows without modeling edge cases – early workers, late shoppers – they often create unfair cost spikes. A well-designed parking policy should use demand-based pricing that smooths the transition, not a hard cutoff.”
The city has not yet set a date for the public hearing on the parking review, but council members expect to open comment period by mid-April.
For now, downtown workers like the anonymous accountant say they’re left with few choices. “I either pay the extra $80 a month, or I add 20 minutes to my commute by parking in a residential zone and walking. Neither is great for a city that says it wants to attract people downtown.”









