Share

July 15, 2025 — A major motoring organization is pushing for a streamlined path for drivers who pass automatic-only tests to get behind the wheel of a manual car after just one hour of targeted instruction. The proposal, aimed at cutting through the current driving test backlog, has sparked debate on both sides of the Atlantic about whether such a shortcut compromises road safety or simply modernizes an outdated system.
The UK-based AA (Automobile Association) — the country’s largest motoring services group — has formally called on the government to approve a one-hour conversion lesson delivered by certified driving schools. Under the current rules, someone who passes an automatic driving test can only drive automatic vehicles. To drive a manual car — for work, rental, or borrowing a friend’s vehicle — they must pass an entirely separate test in a manual car. But with average wait times for a manual test slot reaching nearly 22 weeks in May 2025 (compared to about five weeks in February 2020 before the pandemic), the AA argues the requirement is impractical and unfair.
“Most drivers of automatic cars quickly develop good road skills, so it doesn’t make sense to force them to spend months overcoming the driving test backlog just to borrow a manual car,” Edmund King, AA president, told the Press Association. “Such a one-hour conversion course would help those who may occasionally need to drive a manual car do so legally. This would be more pragmatic than retesting them in a manual vehicle when the DVSA is struggling to get rid of the current test backlog.”
The AA’s proposal comes at a time when the proportion of learners taking automatic driving tests in Britain is at a record high — 29.4% of all tests in the last financial year, up from about 4% in 2007/08. The surge is partly driven by the rise of electric vehicles, which typically lack a conventional gearbox and thus require only automatic-type tests. Many learners also choose automatics for the perceived ease of “ditching the clutch, gear stick and difficult hill starts,” as King noted.
However, the UK’s Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency (DVSA) has pushed back. A spokesperson said: “For the safety of all road users, anyone wishing to drive a manual car must pass a manual driving test, and we have no plans to change this.” The DVSA has been tackling the test backlog by recruiting more examiners, training them faster, using military examiners, and reforming the booking process to combat misuse.
What about the United States?
While the AA’s proposal is a UK-specific issue, it raises an interesting contrast with U.S. driver licensing practices. In the United States, there is no federal requirement for a separate manual driving test. Each state sets its own rules, and the vast majority of states do not distinguish between automatic and manual transmissions on a standard driver’s license. For example, in California, Florida, Texas, and New York, the road test is typically conducted in whichever vehicle the applicant brings, and the license issued is valid for both automatic and manual cars. A handful of states — such as Illinois and Michigan — used to have a manual restriction notation, but those have largely been phased out or are rarely enforced. In practice, if you pass the test in an automatic, you can legally drive a manual car in nearly every state.
“The U.S. approach is far more pragmatic than the UK’s,” said Dr. Sarah Mitchell, a transportation policy researcher at the University of Michigan. “In high-demand areas with long wait times for road tests, requiring a separate manual test creates an unnecessary barrier. The key is whether the driver has actually learned to operate a manual safely. A one-hour conversion course, if well-designed, could be a reasonable compromise — but it would need to cover clutch control, hill starts, and emergency maneuvers thoroughly.”
Safety vs. practicality
Critics of the AA’s proposal worry that one hour is insufficient to develop the muscle memory and hazard awareness required for manual driving. Manual transmission vehicles require coordinating the clutch, gear stick, and accelerator — a skill that can take many hours of practice to master. Proponents counter that the current system forces drivers to wait months for a test they may never need again, simply because they occasionally need to borrow a manual car. The AA’s one-hour course would be a standalone conversion lesson, not a fully retested ride — but it would still be delivered by a certified instructor and endorsed by the government.
The debate mirrors broader tensions in the auto industry, where electric vehicles (EVs) — nearly all automatics — are replacing traditional manual cars. In the UK, manual car sales have fallen to less than 30% of new car registrations, according to the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT). In the US, manual transmission vehicles accounted for just 1.2% of new car sales in 2024, according to data from Edmunds. The practical need for a manual license is shrinking, yet millions of existing manual cars remain on the road — and many drivers still want the option.
What’s next?
The AA has submitted its proposal to the UK Department for Transport, but no formal review has been announced. In the meantime, learner drivers in the UK continue to face the frustrations of the test backlog. The DVSA has pledged to clear the backlog by the end of 2025, but critics remain skeptical.
For American drivers, the lesson is clear: U.S. licensing rules are already more flexible, but they could benefit from a more structured conversion program for those who learned solely on automatics and want to drive a manual. As the automotive landscape shifts toward EVs, the debate over driver training standards will only intensify.
“The AA’s proposal is a sensible, modern approach that respects both safety and convenience,” King concluded. “We hope the government will consider it seriously.”









