Share

Owning a private island in the United States is a more attainable goal than many realize, with several properties currently on the market for under $2 million. Based on our experience assessment, this price point offers opportunities for a secluded retreat without the billionaire price tag, focusing on cozy residences and unique natural settings rather than extreme luxury.
What Private Islands Are Available for Under $2 Million? A search of current listings reveals several private islands with homes, primarily in the Northeastern and Mid-Atlantic regions, offering a range of experiences from rustic escapes to more developed properties.
Honeymoon Island, Hammond, NY - $859,000: Located in the Thousand Islands region on the St. Lawrence River, this quarter-acre island features a fully furnished, 1,800-square-foot contemporary cottage with three bedrooms. The property is considered a turnkey property, meaning it is ready for immediate use and occupancy. It includes a private boat dock and is ideal for boating and fishing enthusiasts.
Ben Island, Harpswell, ME - $1,995,000: This 4-acre retreat is a short boat ride from the Maine coast. The main residence is a renovated post-and-beam cottage with three bedrooms. Key features include a modern solar energy system and a conventional septic system, which is uncommon for offshore islands and handles wastewater treatment on-site.
Tippity Wichity Island, Park Hall, MD - $1,995,000: Situated in a protected cove of the Chesapeake Bay, this 5-acre island appeals to nature lovers. The property includes a three-bedroom home, a private dock with a boat lift, and a swimming pool. The surrounding St. Marys River is known for being swimmable in the summer months.
Rice Lake Property, Whitewater, WI - $1,800,000: This unique offering includes a main house on the mainland and a private island with a rustic cabin. The primary residence is a custom-built, five-bedroom home designed for entertaining, while the island cabin provides a more adventurous lodging option for guests.
Harnden Island, Orcas Island, WA - $1,075,000: For those seeking a Pacific Northwest experience, this 1.9-acre island is located near the Sucia Island Marine State Park. The property is largely undeveloped, featuring a small A-frame cabin and granting access to the state park's guest dock and trails.
What Are the Practical Considerations of Island Ownership? The reality of owning a private island involves logistical factors that differ from mainland property ownership. Maintenance and access are inherently more complex and costly. You will be responsible for your own power, water, and waste management systems, as seen with the solar array and septic system on Ben Island. All access is typically by boat, requiring you to factor in the cost of vessel ownership, docking, and navigating seasonal weather. Properties often require a higher level of self-sufficiency.
Is Financing a Private Island Different from a Standard Home? Financing can be a significant hurdle. Many lenders are hesitant to provide a standard mortgage—a loan specifically for purchasing real estate—for private islands because they are considered unique and potentially difficult to resell. As a result, buyers should be prepared for the possibility of needing a larger down payment or exploring alternative financing options, such as a portfolio loan. A thorough appraisal, which is a professional assessment of a property's market value, is crucial.
What Are the Key Steps in the Purchase Process? The transaction process shares similarities with buying any home but requires additional due diligence.
Purchasing a private island is a major decision that combines a unique lifestyle with significant responsibilities. The key is to approach the purchase with thorough research and realistic expectations about the associated costs and maintenance. By focusing on due diligence and understanding the unique aspects of island ownership, this dream can become a manageable reality.









