Browse
Log in / Register
Share
For homeowners of older properties, a strategic renovation that prioritizes functional living space over sheer room count can significantly increase property value. A recent project on a 1906 Craftsman home in Everett, Washington, demonstrated that a $60,000 investment, which included removing a poorly placed bedroom and bathroom, transformed an unsellable property. The renovation led to a purchase offer of $515,000—a substantial increase over the original $390,000 asking price. The key takeaway is that creating a desirable, modern flow often outweighs the traditional metric of maximizing bedroom count.
Conventional wisdom suggests that more bedrooms and bathrooms always command a higher price. However, this is not an absolute rule. In the case of the Everett Craftsman, a previous owner had added a first-floor bedroom and bathroom adjacent to the kitchen to accommodate mobility needs. While well-intentioned, this addition fragmented the main living area. The renovation experts made the difficult decision to remove this suite to create a larger, open-concept living and dining space. This change, though it reduced the official bedroom count, ultimately created a more marketable and functional floor plan for a modern family. The decision to prioritize flow and light over an additional, awkwardly placed bedroom proved to be the correct financial move.
Incorporating authentic, character-rich details is crucial when updating a historic home. A cost-effective method demonstrated in this project was the installation of a transom window—a window placed above a door or another window—over an interior doorway. This $400 addition mirrored the original transom above the front door, enhancing architectural continuity and allowing more light to flow between rooms. Similarly, adding shiplap—a style of wooden board with a rabbet joint that creates a tight fit—to the kitchen ceiling for $1,500 introduced texture and a cozy, cottage feel. These elements preserved the home's Craftsman charm without requiring a major financial investment.
Achieving a balance between preserving original character and meeting contemporary expectations is the cornerstone of a successful historic home renovation. In the upstairs bathroom, the original tile pattern was beloved but the tiles themselves were faded. The solution was to replace the flooring with a new tile that offered a modern interpretation of the historic design. This approach honored the home's heritage while ensuring durability and modern appeal. In the mudroom, peel-and-stick wallpaper provided an inexpensive yet impactful way to inject style and personality instantly. These choices demonstrate that modernization does not require erasing a home's history.
The primary goal of any pre-sale renovation is to achieve a strong Return on Investment (ROI), which is the profit from an investment relative to its cost. In this case, the initial $60,000 renovation budget was allocated toward high-impact changes: reconfiguring the layout, updating the kitchen, and refreshing key spaces with character-appropriate details. The pre-renovation market rejection at $390,000 indicated that the property's value was suppressed by its dated condition and poor flow. Post-renovation, the property's value was assessed to be at least $500,000, representing a significant value uplift. The final sale at $515,000 validated the strategic allocation of the renovation budget. A focused investment on correcting functional flaws and enhancing aesthetic appeal can yield a powerful ROI, even if it involves counterintuitive steps like removing a bedroom.
Based on the experience from this renovation, homeowners should focus on improving the quality and flow of living spaces rather than simply adding rooms. Strategic, character-appropriate updates like transom windows, shiplap accents, and modernized historic designs can dramatically increase appeal without excessive cost. Ultimately, understanding what modern buyers value in a historic home is the most critical factor in planning a profitable renovation.
