ok.com
Browse
Log in / Register

Resilient, not lean: SA companies must refocus

OKer_bv0hbm9
10/07/2026, 06:56:18 AM
SA companies

South African business leaders have spent years under the spell of lean. They have cut inventory, trimmed headcount and squeezed working capital to survive in an economy that does not forgive weakness. But after load-shedding, port congestion, floods and cyber attacks, the lean playbook has made many companies more exposed, not less. As of May 10, 2026, the conversation in boardrooms needs to change. Efficiency is not the same as resilience. In fact, a business that is very lean can be very fragile.

The two words sound like they belong together, but they point in opposite directions. A lean company is optimised for normal conditions. It strips away anything that does not contribute directly to output, cost or speed. A resilient company is built for abnormal conditions. It keeps extra capacity, alternative suppliers and decision-making autonomy so that it can absorb a shock and keep serving customers. Both approaches have value, but they require different resources. The problem starts when a company treats one as the substitute for the other.

South Africa has provided enough real-world tests. During the worst electricity shortages, plants that had invested in solar and backup diesel still discovered that fuel logistics, maintenance skills and working capital limits could bring them to a stop. During the container congestion at Durban, retailers with "lean" inventories watched empty shelves appear within days. After severe flooding in KwaZulu-Natal, factories that had no redundant production lines could not switch output quickly enough. None of these failures were caused by poor products or lazy workers. They were caused by a system that had been deliberately hollowed out to look efficient.

Lean thinking makes a company look good on paper. Inventory turns improve. Staff costs fall. Operating margins get healthier. The trouble is that many of those indicators measure the business in calm weather. They say nothing about what the business can do when the grid is down, the port is clogged or a supplier in another country leaves the market. There is no line item on an income statement for "ability to survive the next crisis." That does not mean the ability is free; it just means it is easy to ignore until it is too late.

Many executives make the mistake of rebranding cost cuts as resilience. They say the company is becoming "more agile" when it is actually becoming smaller. They call a hiring freeze "streamlining" when it means the remaining staff are overloaded. They call an aggressive reduction in stock "efficient" when it leaves the business unable to respond to a single missed shipment. This language is dangerous. If every reduction is labelled as progress, there is no incentive to ask whether the company is cutting its means of recovery.

Resilience is not the same as holding cash in a vault. It is a set of capabilities that can be designed and measured. For instance, a resilient company knows which inventory items are critical and ensures they are protected. It knows which suppliers can replace each other if the first choice fails. It has maintenance plans that do not stretch every asset to breaking point. It has decision rules for the first 48 hours of an emergency. These capabilities are not waste. They are operational insurance, and in South Africa the premium is painfully necessary.

The human side gets ignored most often. Lean programmes tend to flatten teams, remove backups and push more responsibility onto fewer people. That can appear productive until someone is sick, resigns or has to leave for family reasons. Institutional memory is not easily rebuilt. A resilient company does not need huge teams, but it does need people who have been trained across roles and given the authority to respond without waiting for approval from someone who is unreachable. In a crisis, speed depends on trust as much as on procedures.

Supplier relationships deserve a second look. A single foreign source can make procurement costs look excellent, but it concentrates risk. South African manufacturers that started considering local alternatives after the shipping disruptions were not being sentimental. They were reducing their dependence on long routes, strike-prone ports and exchange-rate swings. Local supply is rarely the cheapest option in a spreadsheet. It is often the safer option because it shortens the chain between the supplier and the customer.

The same logic applies to assets. A factory running at 98 percent utilisation is less flexible than one running at 85 percent. The lost margin slots are actually spare capacity that can be used when something goes wrong elsewhere. The same is true for delivery vehicles, software systems and even management time. There is a big difference between being busy and being prepared. The company that is always at full capacity is also the company that cannot redirect resources when an unexpected order arrives or an essential route fails.

Recovery time is the real test. A lean company can report a wonderful annual result. A resilient company can answer one simple question: if our main facility stopped working for a week, or our biggest supplier missed a shipment, or electricity was unavailable for five consecutive days, how long would it take us to serve customers at 80 percent capacity? Many South African businesses cannot answer that question honestly. The ones that can are the ones making resilience decisions now, not after the next emergency.

There are signs that outside capital is starting to pay attention to this difference. Banks, insurers and long-term investors have become more interested in how companies handle operational risk. A business with backup power, tested crisis plans and redundant supply routes may carry higher costs than a leaner competitor. It may also be a better borrower. In an economy where power, logistics and public infrastructure can all fail in the same year, the cheapest company is not automatically the safest company.

This is not an excuse to overspend. South African business does not need careless costs or fat headcounts. It needs discipline, but discipline must be applied to resilience itself. That means deciding where to hold buffers and where to stay lean. No company can protect itself everywhere. A bank may need expensive data redundancy; a small clothing retailer may not. A food manufacturer may need dual sources for packaging; a software firm may not face the same exposure. The point is to make the choice deliberately, not to let every buffer disappear accidentally.

The public conversation matters as much as the balance sheet. When an executive says the company is "cutting fat to become resilient", that sounds strong, but it usually means the opposite. Fat is not the issue. Slack is. Slack gives the organisation room to breathe when the environment shifts. In a stable economy, much of that slack can be removed safely. In South Africa, removing all of it is a bet against history.

The country has now had enough hard lessons to stop treating resilience as a trend. The companies that survived the worst disruptions were not the ones with the sharpest cost ratios. They were the ones with substitutes, flexibility and people who could act. Those advantages are not romantic ideas. They are practical features that appear in market share, customer loyalty and the ability to keep paying suppliers while others close down.

What South Africa actually needs is not just resilient companies. It needs resilient networks. Even the best-run business will struggle if its supplier, distributor and customers are all failing at the same time. That is another reason why local collaboration matters. When firms share logistics information, coordinate on alternative routes and support regional suppliers, they create slack that helps the whole system. Individual resilience is valuable, but shared resilience is stronger.

South African leaders must stop confusing lean with resilient. Lean is a method. Resilience is a purpose. A company can be both, but only if it refuses to sacrifice the latter in the name of the former. The next crisis is not a question of if. It is a question of which combination of power cuts, shipping delays, storms or network failures will arrive first. Companies that have planned for that moment will not always be the most efficient, but they will still be standing. In a country this volatile, standing is the better benchmark.

Cookie
Cookie Settings
Our Apps
Download
Download on the
APP Store
Download
Get it on
Google Play
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.