Browse
Log in / Register
Share
As of March 25, 2025, a rollout of new ticketless parking machines at Northallerton’s Applegarth Short Stay Car Park and High Street has left local drivers frustrated over confusing interfaces, rising costs for longer stays, and fears that cars will shift to nearby residential streets. The North Yorkshire Council says the machines, which require entering a full vehicle registration number before selecting a duration, are part of a county-wide shift toward more reliable, paperless systems.
Free first hour now requires registration entry
The council maintains that the first hour remains free, but drivers must now type in their entire license plate number to claim it. Several motorists told reporters the process is harder than the old push-button ticket machines. One said, “It was so much easier just to press a button and get a ticket for free parking without having to put reg in.” Another added, “Why change it? Seemed to work well enough as it was.”
Council officials argue the new units feature larger screens and a simpler interface, making them easier to use overall. However, field observations suggest many users still struggle, especially older drivers unfamiliar with keypads.
Confusion around how the free hour works with longer stays
Residents have questioned the logic of the free hour when they need to park for longer periods. One driver asked publicly, “So can I park for three hours at £1.70? One hour free and two hours at £1.70.” The council confirmed the tariff structure remains unchanged: the free hour applies to the first hour of any stay, then the remaining hours are charged at the standard rate.
Others wondered whether they could pay via a mobile app or extend their stay without returning to the machine. The council responded that alternative payment methods, including app-based options, are available if the machine breaks down, but extending a session still requires visiting the machine or using the app for the entire transaction.
Price hikes sting daily commuters
Workers who use the car park daily have condemned the pricing. One motorist complained, “Now £12.30 for eight hours. Guess I’m going to have to look at other options to park whilst at work.” The council insists that charges have not increased as part of the new technology; the amounts were already set in the existing parking order, which was updated in late 2024.
The full tariff, effective Monday to Saturday from 8 am to 6 pm, including bank holidays, is:
These rates are notably higher than many other towns in North Yorkshire, which has prompted criticism that the council is using the system upgrade as a cover for price hikes—a claim the authority denies.
Spillover parking fears intensify
Residents who live on streets near the car park, such as Upwell Road, worry that drivers seeking free or cheaper options will clog their private roads. One local said, “Already a plague of people parking in our private road which is clearly marked ‘resident only parking’.” Another predicted, “Going to be fun down Upwell Road and surrounding areas then.”
The council has acknowledged these concerns, stating it will monitor the situation and “review any serious problems.” It urges residents to report issues directly via email at Parking.sca@northyorks.gov.uk.
Only one machine working? Council says alternatives exist
During a recent visit, a driver reported that only one of the new machines was operational. The council said alternative payment methods, including mobile payments and the ability to pay at other machines within the car park, are always available when an individual unit is out of service. It added that it is actively monitoring the rollout and gathering feedback to address teething problems.
Receipts still available for work expenses
Workers who need receipts to reclaim parking costs can still obtain them through the machine or digital payment confirmations. The council confirmed that paper receipts are printed upon request, and digital receipts can be downloaded from the payment app.
Not all feedback is negative
Despite the complaints, some residents have welcomed the change. One member of the public commented, “At least there will be less ticket litter in the car park.” Another called the charges “very reasonable.” The council points to these positives as evidence that the system has merit.
Transfer of unused time not allowed
The new registration-based system prevents drivers from transferring unused parking time to another person. The council said this rule is identical to the old paper ticket system, which also did not allow transfers. Blue Badge holders can still park for free without entering their registration, provided their disabled parking permit is clearly displayed.
Expert perspective from across the Atlantic
To offer broader context, parking technology consultant Mark Sanders of Urban Mobility Solutions in Chicago notes that similar registration-based systems have been trialed in several U.S. cities including San Francisco and Portland. “The transition from ticket-based to pay-by-plate systems often triggers consumer backlash, particularly when the interface is not intuitive,” Sanders told [publication name]. “Councils need to invest in clear signage, user testing, and a grace period for learning before judging the system’s success.”
Sanders added that Northallerton’s approach of keeping the free hour but requiring registration entry may confuse first-time users. “If the goal is environmental and operational efficiency, they should consider offering an app-first option that remembers users’ plates and allows seamless payment without keypad entry.”
Council’s final word
North Yorkshire Council reiterated that traffic wardens will continue to issue fines for non-compliance and that the new machines are part of a wider modernization effort. “We will keep monitoring the rollout and gathering feedback as drivers get used to the system,” a spokesperson said. The authority encourages all users to report issues via the parking team email.
With no plans to revert to paper tickets, local drivers and residents must adapt—or continue voicing their dissatisfaction to the council.
