ok.com
Browse
Log in / Register

Haredi parties may endorse neither Netanyahu nor Eisenkot

OKer_pg8avqz
10/13/2026, 08:25:55 AM
Haredi parties

On April 26, 2026, The Jerusalem Post reported that Israel’s two most influential ultra-Orthodox parties — Shas and United Torah Judaism — are likely to withhold their recommendation from both Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Chief of Staff Gadi Eisenkot when President Isaac Herzog begins post-election consultations. Sources described the parties’ preference for neutrality, at least until the divisive issue of military conscription for Haredi men is resolved. With no bloc holding an obvious majority, their decision could delay coalition negotiations for several weeks.

The report, based on conversations with people close to the religious parties, says that Shas and UTJ are not currently inclined to name any preferred candidate to the presidency. They are also, according to the same sources, not expected to work actively to replace Netanyahu or to assist the opposition in ousting Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana. The message from Jerusalem’s ultra-Orthodox corridors is that they are prepared to wait.

Conscription dispute drives hesitation

At the heart of the hesitation is the long-running battle over compulsory service for yeshiva students. Shas and UTJ insist that full-time Torah study is a legitimate alternative to army service, a claim challenged by secular parties and large parts of the Israeli public. The religious parties want a new legal framework that secures their community’s exemption from conscription, but they have learned, sometimes bitterly, that such legislation often collapses under judicial scrutiny.

Even if the Knesset manages to pass a new drafting law, the ultra-Orthodox leadership may still delay a decision on joining a future coalition. They remain concerned that the High Court of Justice will invalidate the arrangement, as it has in previous cases. Entering a government whose central pledge collapses in the Supreme Court would be a professional and political embarrassment the religious parties prefer to avoid.

No final decision yet

Sources stress that these are assessments, not decisions by the rabbinical councils that guide Shas and UTJ. The final authority sits with the sages who head each movement. They may adjust their position once the final results are in and once they see how coalition negotiations are moving.

In the past, the Haredi parties have been patient players. They let Likud and its rivals struggle for a trajectory, then demand higher prices. The current stalemate gives them that opportunity once again.

Opposition’s parliamentary plan

Meanwhile, the opposition bloc is preparing for a fragmented electoral outcome. One scenario under discussion is replacing Amir Ohana as Speaker when the newly elected Knesset convenes. If the anti-Netanyahu parties can rally a majority around an alternative candidate, they would control the House agenda and can advance legislation for a state commission of inquiry into the October 7 attacks and a constitutional limit of two terms for any prime minister. Both initiatives are widely seen as aimed, at least in part, at Netanyahu.

Haredi sources cited in the report believe that the same majority needed to replace Ohana could later become the kernel of a government. Possible configurations include a minority government supported from outside by Ra’am, an Islamist party rooted in the Arab sector, or an expanded coalition with Ra’am as a formal partner. But Shas and UTJ are unlikely to actively help the opposition unseat Ohana, and may simply wait for the final results on October 27.

The art of strategic silence

For the ultra-Orthodox parties, withholding a recommendation is more than a negotiating tactic; it is a statement of independence. It tells both Netanyahu and his rivals that their support cannot be assumed. Historically, the religious parties have been most effective when they stay elusive, collecting concessions from whichever candidate eventually achieves a majority. This year, the prize they seek is a legally bulletproof conscription solution, and neither side appears able to offer one.

Observers note that this election may produce one of the most fragmented Knessets in recent history. Under Israel’s Basic Law, the president assigns the task of forming a government to a member of Knesset who, in his judgment, stands the best chance of mustering 61 seats. The recommendations of party leaders are a formal step but not a binding one. A party that stays silent sends a message that it expects the current prime minister to be defeated — or at least to be forced into painful concessions. For President Herzog, that may mean inviting Netanyahu or Eisenkot to try despite the Haredi parties’ abstention.

Netanyahu and the Haredi dilemma

For the Likud leader, losing the endorsement of Shas and UTJ, even temporarily, would be an early setback. These two parties have anchored almost every coalition he has led. Together with other lists, they provided the parliamentary cushion that allowed his governments to survive votes of no confidence. In the consultation phase, their neutrality would weaken his claim that he can present a solid 61-member majority, and it would push him into a prolonged round of private negotiations at a time when his party is fighting for political survival.

There is a nuance: not recommending Netanyahu does not mean abandoning him. The ultra-Orthodox leadership may simply decline to provide a public recommendation until they see what he is willing to commit to on conscription. Their stance could therefore be a signal to Likud that better terms are needed.

Eisenkot and the opposition’s math

The former chief of staff, a moderate and security-minded figure, has limited appeal within the religious community. The opposition understands that a coalition led by Eisenkot — or by someone close to him — would still need support from a bloc that is not exclusively secular. Ra’am might provide that support, but including an Arab party in a formal alliance would compel its partner parties to abandon long-held prejudices. It is a difficult move, politically and ideologically.

Haredi sources believe Shas and UTJ will not actively help the opposition replace Ohana, but they might not block the move if it leads to a more favourable bargaining environment. In other words, the religious parties are comfortable with a degree of political chaos as long as it increases their own leverage.

Looking ahead to October

The election campaign is still in its early stages. All players know that the final coalition arithmetic will be clear only after the ballots are counted. In the meantime, the Haredi parties have clearly signalled that they are not committed to anyone. The power they hold comes from being the last people asked — and, if the Jerusalem Post report is accurate, they intend to remain unasked for as long as possible.

This dynamic may frustrate Israelis hoping for a quick end to the political gridlock. But it also indicates that even parties often described as narrowly sectoral are thinking about institutional strength, not just the allocation of ministerial portfolios. For the religious community, the next government is about preserving a way of life. Everything else is secondary.

Cookie
Cookie Settings
Our Apps
Download
Download on the
APP Store
Download
Get it on
Google Play
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.