Share

May 16, 2026 — A 24-year-old gym regular was happy when his girlfriend wanted to train at the same facility. He added her to his membership, built her a starter workout plan, and bought the gear she asked for. After roughly two months of no-shows, he is asking himself what many people in the same situation want to know: Am I wrong to cancel an unused membership? The short answer from Reddit is no.
The man, posting in the Am I the A**hole subreddit as "24M," explained that his girlfriend "22F" asked to join his gym. Because the couple trains at the same location, the simplest route seemed to be adding her as an additional member on his existing plan for an extra monthly fee. He already paid for his own membership, but the add-on was an added expense he was willing to cover—until it produced no results.
According to the post, the boyfriend didn't just give her access. He created a simple, beginner-friendly routine and arranged a schedule around her work shift. He also bought every piece of clothing, equipment, and fitness accessory she requested. He did it without trying to control her, and he says he never lectured her about missing workouts. His goal was to make the gym as easy to start as possible.
Then the pattern emerged. The girlfriend has not been to the gym in about two months. Instead of using the training plan or the mornings she said she would use for workouts, she has been sleeping in and spending time on her phone. The boyfriend brought it up once, a few weeks ago, after he realized how much money he had put into gear and gym-related purchases. She told him she would start going again, but she didn't follow through.
More recently, the man asked his girlfriend if she wanted to work out with him, noting that they rarely get to train together. She said yes. But when he came home from work to pick her up, she said she didn't really want to go. He also noticed that she has found time to meet a coworker after work and even before work on some mornings, yet she hasn't been able to make the gym part of her routine.
In the post, he wrote: "AITA for canceling the membership? I feel like it's a waste of money at this point." His reasoning was straightforward: there's no point in paying for something that never gets used.
The response from commenters was almost unanimous. "His money, his decision," one person wrote. Another said the membership should be canceled because the girlfriend's behavior shows she isn't interested, and continuing to pay could enable guilt or resentment. While a few commenters cautioned that the conversation should be handled with respect, most agreed that a permanent monthly charge cannot be justified by intention alone.
Several commenters suggested a middle ground: switch to guest passes. If the girlfriend decides she wants to train again, the man can bring her as a guest for the day without carrying the cost of a full monthly add-on. That way, the couple isn't losing access or flexibility, but they also aren't paying for a plan that sits idle.
The story is a clean example of what personal finance experts call "subscription creep." Gyms, like many subscription services, rely on revenue from members who barely visit. For individuals, the same dynamic often appears in streaming plans, unused apps, and gym memberships. The result is a recurring charge that quietly drains money without delivering any real benefit.
In this case, the boyfriend recognized that trap. His decision to cancel isn't a rejection of his girlfriend or her fitness goals. It is a simple accounting move: a service that isn't being used should not be a regular expense.
Before calling the gym, anyone in a similar situation should check the membership agreement. Some clubs allow members to remove an additional person quickly. Others may require a visit or a conversation with staff. A few gyms offer the option to freeze an add-on for a month or two, which gives the person time to decide whether they actually want to use the facility.
Communication matters, too. Rather than making the decision sound like punishment, the conversation can be framed as a shared budget choice: "Since you haven't been able to get to the gym, I'm going to take the extra monthly fee off my card. Whenever you want to come back, we can look at a guest pass." That keeps the tone neutral and leaves the door open.
This particular Reddit post resonates because it is so common. One partner wants to build a new habit. The other partner tries to make it happen. Then the motivation fades, and the gym membership enters the category of "good intentions." Cancelation is not about being unkind; it's about being realistic.
Reddit's verdict is that the boyfriend is not the a**hole. He invested time, money, and energy into a plan that was never used. At a certain point, the fair financial decision is to stop paying for it. If his girlfriend later wants to train, she can carry that motivation—and the cost—herself.
A gym membership only creates value when someone actually walks through the door. In this case, the smartest move is cancel, keep the guest-pass option open, and let the girlfriend decide when she is ready to show up.









