ok.com
Browse
Log in / Register

Cell phone use in car crashes vastly underreported, study finds

OKer_ajfe9kk
08/27/2026, 08:43:22 PM
cell phone use

April 1, 2025 – A new study from the University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute reveals that cell phone use is a factor in motor vehicle crashes far more often than official police reports suggest, raising serious questions about the accuracy of national distracted driving statistics.

The study, published in the Journal of Safety Research, analyzed more than 6,000 crash reports from seven states between 2019 and 2023. Researchers cross-referenced police records with cell phone call and text logs obtained from drivers who voluntarily consented to share their data after the crashes. The results were striking: in crashes where the driver admitted using a phone at the time of the incident, only 38% of those cases were recorded by police as involving a cell phone.

“We found that the official data captures less than half of the real-world cell phone use in crashes,” said Dr. Emily Carter, lead author of the study. “This means that the public and policymakers are working with a flawed picture of how big the distracted driving problem really is.”

Why police reports miss the mark

The discrepancy stems from several factors. Drivers often fail to admit phone use due to fear of fines or insurance hikes. Officers may not ask about phone use if no signs of distraction are obvious, and in some jurisdictions, there is no checkbox on crash forms for “cell phone use” unless a citation is issued. Additionally, witnesses are rarely able to confirm phone use.

“Police rely on what drivers tell them, and drivers have every incentive to lie,” said retired Ohio State Highway Patrol Lieutenant Mark Jensen, who was not involved in the study. “Unless we have a phone log or a witness, we often have to guess.”

Exclusive angle: New technology could close the gap

The study arrives as automakers and tech companies introduce new tools to detect phone use. Apple’s iOS 18.4, released in March 2025, includes a “Crash Reporting” feature that automatically logs whether the driver’s phone was in use at the time of impact. Similarly, Google’s Android Auto is testing a “Distraction Snapshot” that records screen-on and call status immediately before a crash. These features could provide objective data, but privacy advocates warn against mandatory reporting.

“The potential for better data is enormous, but it must be voluntary and anonymized,” said Dr. Carter. “We don’t want to create a surveillance system, but we do need to understand the true scope of the problem.”

Numbers tell a different story

According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), cell phone use was cited in just 3.2% of all crashes in 2023. The University of Michigan study estimates the real figure is between 8% and 12%, based on phone logs and follow-up interviews. For fatal crashes, underreporting was even more severe—only 12% of fatal crashes involving a cell phone were flagged as such in police records.

“This is a huge gap,” said Dr. Jake Miller, a traffic safety researcher at the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) who reviewed the study’s methodology. “If we only see 3% but the real number is 10%, we’re undercounting the risk by a factor of three. That misinforms everything from public awareness campaigns to insurance rates.”

Regional differences emerge

The study found that underreporting varies by state. In states with primary enforcement of texting bans (where police can stop a driver solely for phone use), reporting rates were higher—around 60% of actual phone-related crashes were recorded. In states with secondary enforcement, reporting dropped to 30%. “Laws appear to influence not just behavior but also the accuracy of data collection,” noted Dr. Carter.

What this means for drivers and policymakers

The findings have immediate implications. NHTSA relies on police-reported data to set safety priorities, and the agency’s “Distracted Driving” campaign budget is based on those numbers. If the true incidence is higher, funding may be insufficient. Additionally, auto insurance companies use crash data to set premiums; underreporting could mean that drivers who are not at fault are paying more while distracted drivers are not penalized.

“We need to update the way we collect crash data,” said Senator Maria Gonzalez (D-CA), who chairs the Senate Commerce Subcommittee on Transportation Safety. “Automated reporting from vehicles and phones, with proper privacy protections, could give us a much clearer picture.”

Reader takeaway

While the study is observational and relies on self-reported phone logs, its methodology is robust. The researchers note that the sample skewed toward younger drivers, who are more likely to use phones, but even after adjusting for age, the underreporting rate remained high.

For everyday drivers, the message is clear: even if you think you can hide your phone use, the data is starting to catch up. And for the safety community, the study underscores that the fight against distracted driving is only as good as the data we have.

The full study, “Underreporting of Cell Phone Use in Motor Vehicle Crashes in the United States,” is available in the Journal of Safety Research (Vol. 88, 2025).

Cookie
Cookie Settings
Our Apps
Download
Download on the
APP Store
Download
Get it on
Google Play
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.