ok.com
Browse
Log in / Register

Car Seat Mistakes: 3 Common Errors Utah Experts Warn About

OKer_7j6amdn
09/28/2026, 01:33:22 PM
car seat mistakes

SALT LAKE CITY — It's Child Passenger Safety Week in Utah, and safety officials are using it to confront a stubborn statistic: more than two-thirds of car seats are installed or used incorrectly — an error rate that, in a crash, could mean the difference between a bruise and a catastrophic injury. Published Sept. 20, 2024.

Intermountain Health's Primary Children's Hospital and the Utah Department of Public Safety's Highway Safety Office have spent the week — observed nationally Sept. 15-21 — urging parents and caregivers to take a fresh look at how children are riding. State data puts Utah's car-seat misuse rate at 67.5%, slightly above the national average of roughly 65%. Both figures have remained stubbornly high for years, and safety experts say the old way of teaching — handing out checklists and moving on — isn't changing the outcome.

"It's not a problem of will. Parents want their kids to be safe," says Sarah Knudsen, a certified child passenger safety technician at Primary Children's Hospital. "Where it falls apart is education. Adults are never shown exactly why each strap, clip, and anchor matters. So this year, we're teaching the physics, not just the rules."

That approach matters because a car-seat error doesn't have to look dramatic to be deadly. A tether left loose, a booster retired a year early, or a child riding shotgun before age 13 can all turn a survivable collision into a tragedy. Nationwide, motor-vehicle crashes remain one of the leading causes of death for children ages 1 to 12, and research from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration shows correctly used restraints reduce the risk of fatal injury by 54% for toddlers and 71% for infants. Closing the gap between those proven numbers and real-world habits is exactly what technicians are working to do.

Here are the three most common mistakes seen at Utah car-seat check stations, the reasons they happen, and the crash science that makes them dangerous.

Mistake No. 1: Skipping or misusing the top tether

The top tether is the strap that runs from the top of a forward-facing car seat to a metal anchor bolted into the vehicle — usually on the rear deck, the back of the seatback, or the ceiling of the cargo area. It's the most overlooked part of a forward-facing installation.

Here's what it does: in a crash, the child's body is thrown forward with tremendous force. Without the tether, the top of the car seat also rotates forward, letting the child's head travel several extra inches. Those extra inches are the difference between the head brushing against the vehicle seat and slamming into it. The tether directly reduces head excursion and protects against severe head and neck injuries.

Technicians say the errors are common: parents never use the tether because they don't know it exists, they attach it to the wrong anchor such as a cargo tie-down, or they route it incorrectly around the headrest. The remedy is simple — read both the vehicle manual and the seat manual, and confirm the tether clicks into the designated anchor — yet few families do it without prompting.

Mistake No. 2: Retiring the booster seat too early

Booster seats exist for one reason: adult seat belts don't fit child bodies. On a typical child, a lap belt rides up across the stomach — where the organs are vulnerable — and the shoulder belt slices across the neck. In a crash, that misplaced belt can cause severe internal abdominal injuries known as "seat belt syndrome," as well as spinal and neck damage.

Most children are not ready to use a seat belt alone until they reach about 4 feet 9 inches tall — usually somewhere between ages 8 and 12. Height, not age, is the threshold. A 7-year-old who is already tall may pass the test; a 12-year-old who is short likely won't. To assess readiness, technicians recommend the five-step test: the child's back must be flat against the vehicle seat, knees bent over the seat edge, feet flat on the floor, lap belt across the hips, and shoulder belt across the middle of the collarbone. If any single step fails, the child stays in the booster.

Parents are often pressured by kids who want to be treated like "big kids." Knudsen hears it regularly — and her answer is consistent: "The belt doesn't care how big you feel. It stops being safe below a certain size."

Mistake No. 3: Moving to the front seat too soon

All children under 13 should ride in the back seat. That's the recommendation of both NHTSA and the American Academy of Pediatrics — and there's no size-based exception.

The reason is airbags. A frontal airbag inflates in about 30 milliseconds at speeds approaching 200 mph. Designed for the larger, stronger bodies of adults, that deployment can strike a child's head and chest with enough energy to cause fatal injuries. Even modern "smart" airbags that suppress deployment based on weight aren't a reason to move a child forward early.

Parents often cite the child's height or maturity as the reason for upgrading to the front seat. Maturity is irrelevant to physics — in a frontal collision, the rear seat keeps children behind the principal impact zone, adding a layer of protection no airbag can fully replace.

Other common errors technicians find

Alongside the top three, inspection stations encounter a few recurring problems worth mentioning:

  • Loose harness straps. After tightening, if any webbing on the harness can be pinched between two fingers, the straps aren't snug enough.
  • Chest clip in the wrong place. The clip belongs at armpit level, over the sternum — not down on the stomach, where it lets harness straps slip off the shoulders.
  • Winter coats and bulky jackets underneath the harness. Down-filled coats compress dramatically in a crash, creating slack that can allow a small child to slide through. The fix is to keep the harness snug against thin layers and place blankets or coats over the buckled child.

Knowing the four stages of car-seat safety

Many misuse problems trace back to a blurry understanding of when children should move from one seat type to the next. The current guidance: rear-facing seats for infants and toddlers — every seat sold today allows rear-facing well beyond age 2; use the manufacturer's stated height and weight limits. Forward-facing seats with a harness and tether generally serve toddlers through preschool. Booster seats come next for school-age children. Seat belts alone should be used only after the five-step test is passed. Every transition should follow the seat's label limits, not the child's birthday or negotiation skills.

Where Utah families can get free help

Free help is available year-round, not just in September. Certified child passenger safety technicians throughout Utah staff inspection stations where they install, adjust, and teach — typically in under an hour. Parents leave with hands-on confidence, not a lecture.

"We want every caregiver to be able to do this themselves, in the dark, in the rain, with a fussy toddler," Knudsen says. "That's the point of education."

Families can find a year-round check station at Clickit.Utah.gov, or make an appointment with Primary Children's Hospital's car seat team at 801-662-CARS.

Cookie
Cookie Settings
Our Apps
Download
Download on the
APP Store
Download
Get it on
Google Play
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.