Share

On Wednesday, April 2, 2025, Appleton police launched a rapid investigation into a series of overnight car break-ins that left residents on the city’s southeast side unsettled. Officers arrested two suspects—an adult man and a teenager—after a stolen vehicle was abandoned in the middle of the road, triggering a chase and a broader search for those responsible.
The incident began around 6 a.m. when a passerby reported an empty car with its doors wide open, sitting in the road near North Cambridge Drive and East Edgemere Drive. Officers responding to the scene quickly determined the vehicle had been stolen from a different part of Appleton. As police arrived, four individuals fled on foot. Officers pursued and apprehended two of them after a short chase. The other two remain at large, and authorities are seeking assistance from the public to identify them.
Throughout the morning, dispatch received multiple calls from neighbors reporting thefts from their vehicles. Investigators are working to determine whether the arrested suspects are connected to those incidents. The Appleton Police Department has urged anyone living in the southeast side to check their vehicles for signs of forced entry or missing items, even if nothing appears missing at first glance.
“We’re asking residents to be vigilant,” said Investigator Yule, who is leading the case. “If you have a doorbell camera or any security footage from Tuesday night into Wednesday morning, please review it and share anything suspicious with us. Even small details can make a big difference.” The department specifically asked that tips be directed to Investigator Yule at 920-832-5540.
In addition to the immediate investigation, police are reminding the community of best practices to prevent auto theft and break-ins. The department’s latest crime prevention bulletin emphasizes three simple steps: lock your doors every time you leave the car—even in your own driveway; remove all valuables or keep them completely out of sight; and report any suspicious activity immediately, rather than waiting until morning.
Local residents expressed frustration and concern. “I’ve lived here for 15 years and never seen anything like this,” said Sarah Lindstrom, a neighbor who lives two blocks from where the stolen car was found. “We’re usually a quiet community. I hope they catch the rest of them.” Others have started neighborhood watch groups and are sharing security camera footage online.
According to Appleton police data, vehicle break-ins have increased by 12% in the first quarter of 2025 compared to the same period last year. Officers attribute much of the rise to unlocked cars and visible valuables left inside. The department plans to hold a community safety meeting next week to address the trend and provide additional prevention tips.
The two arrested suspects were taken to the Outagamie County Jail. The adult male is being held on suspicion of theft and burglary, while the teenager’s charges are pending review by the juvenile court. Their names have not been released pending formal charges. Police continue to investigate whether the suspects are part of a larger group operating in the area.
Anyone with information is urged to call Investigator Yule at 920-832-5540. Anonymous tips can also be submitted through the Appleton Police Department’s website. The department emphasizes that even after the arrest, residents should remain cautious and continue to secure their vehicles.
“This is a good reminder that crime can happen anywhere, anytime,” said Officer Mark Thompson, a public information officer for the Appleton Police Department. “We’re grateful for the community’s quick reporting, which helped us make an arrest. But we need everyone to stay alert and work together to keep our neighborhoods safe.”
As the investigation continues, police are asking residents to share any additional footage or observations from the overnight hours. The department also noted that similar break-ins have been reported in neighboring communities, and they are coordinating with other agencies to determine if there is a wider pattern.
For more information on how to protect your vehicle, visit the Appleton Police Department’s crime prevention page or attend the upcoming community meeting scheduled for April 8, 2025, at the Appleton Public Library. The meeting will include a Q&A session with officers and free steering wheel locks for









