Share

In September 2023, the U.S. housing market experienced a significant slowdown, with home sales and new listings plummeting by approximately 25% and 22% year-over-year, respectively. Despite this sharp decline in activity, the national median home-sale price increased by 8% year-over-year to $403,797. This paradox of rising prices amid falling demand is primarily attributed to a severe shortage of housing supply and persistent inflation, which counteracted the dampening effect of mortgage rates reaching their highest level in two decades.
The primary driver of the market slowdown is the rapid rise in mortgage rates, a type of loan interest rate specifically for purchasing property. These higher borrowing costs have created a dual-sided retreat. For buyers, the monthly mortgage payment on a typical home has surged by more than 50% compared to a year ago, pushing homeownership out of reach for many. For sellers, there is a strong reluctance to list their homes because doing so would mean giving up the historically low mortgage rates they secured during the pandemic. This has led to a sharp reduction in the number of homes available for sale, creating a supply shortage that continues to prop up prices even as demand weakens.
The cooling demand manifested in two key areas: canceled contracts and increased price adjustments. In September, roughly 60,000 home-purchase agreements were canceled, equating to 17% of all homes that went under contract. This was the highest percentage since the initial pandemic shock in March 2020, indicating growing buyer hesitancy. Simultaneously, a record 22% of homes for sale had a price drop as seller expectations began to align with the new market reality of eased buyer competition. The rate of bidding wars, where multiple buyers compete for a single property, fell to a pandemic-era low, with fewer than half of all offers facing competition.
| Metro Area | Year-Over-Year Price Change | Price Drop Percentage |
|---|---|---|
| El Paso, TX | +23.0% | 16.1% |
| Boise, ID | Data Not Specified | 67.8% |
| New Orleans, LA | -5.7% | Data Not Specified |
| San Francisco, CA | -1.9% | 5.5% (Cancellation Rate) |
The pace of the market varied dramatically across the country. The fastest-moving metro was Rochester, NY, where half of all homes went under contract in just 9 days. Other competitive markets included Grand Rapids, MI, and Omaha, NE. In contrast, Chicago, IL, was the slowest market, with a median of 57 days on market. This regional variation highlights that while the national trend is cooling, specific local economies and housing supplies create distinct conditions.
Practical advice for navigating this market: For buyers, the cooling competition and increase in price reductions present an opportunity to negotiate, but budgeting for a significantly higher monthly payment is essential. For sellers, pricing your home competitively from the start is critical to attract the smaller pool of active buyers. Based on our experience assessment, the market's trajectory is heavily dependent on the Federal Reserve's actions to curb inflation, meaning high mortgage rates may persist for several months.









