Share

A recent analysis reveals that nearly 18% of San Francisco home sellers are taking a financial loss on their sales, the highest rate among major U.S. metropolitan areas. This trend is primarily driven by a significant 15% correction in home prices from their pandemic peak. While the San Francisco market faces unique challenges, the national picture remains strong, with over 96% of sellers nationwide still selling their homes for a profit.
The primary reason for losses in San Francisco is the market's sharp price adjustment. The median sale price—the midpoint where half of homes sold for more and half for less—peaked at $1.66 million in April 2022. As of February 2024, it had fallen to $1.41 million, a decrease of $250,000. Homeowners who purchased at nearly any point during the heated 2021-2022 market, when mortgage rates were at historic lows, are now at risk of selling for a loss if they need to move.
Based on our experience assessment, this correction is not solely due to high mortgage rates. A Redfin agent noted that post-pandemic shifts have impacted the city's appeal, including the relocation of some tech employers and changing urban dynamics. Sellers facing a loss are often motivated by life events like job relocation or divorce, as most homeowners who bought recently are choosing to hold their properties.
The situation in San Francisco is an outlier. Nationally, the share of sellers taking a loss is just 4.3%, a rate that has remained relatively stable. The typical, or median, loss amount nationwide is approximately $40,000, significantly lower than San Francisco's median loss of $155,500. This disparity highlights the overall resilience of the U.S. housing market, where the median home-sale price remains just 5% below its 2022 all-time high.
The table below illustrates the metros with the highest and lowest incidence of sellers taking a loss, based on data from the three months ending February 29, 2024.
| Metropolitan Area | Percentage of Sellers Taking a Loss | Median Dollar Loss |
|---|---|---|
| San Francisco, CA | 17.8% | $155,500 |
| Detroit, MI | 10.8% | $16,812 |
| Cleveland, OH | 8.2% | Data Not Specified |
| Providence, RI | 1.2% | Data Not Specified |
| Boston, MA | ~2.0% | Data Not Specified |
| National Average | 4.3% | ~$40,000 |
Source: Redfin analysis of county records and MLS data.
Following San Francisco, the metros with the highest rates of unprofitable sales are primarily in the Midwest and Rust Belt. These include Detroit (10.8%), Cleveland (8.2%), and St. Louis (8.1%). Like San Francisco, these areas have seen home prices fall from their pandemic peaks. In contrast, sellers in New England and Southern California are least likely to lose money. In Providence, RI, only 1.2% of sales resulted in a loss, followed by Boston and Anaheim, CA, at roughly 2%.
It is crucial to emphasize that the vast majority of sellers are still realizing substantial gains. Even in San Francisco, 82% of sellers sold for more than they paid, with a typical gain of $482,000. Nationwide, about 96% of sellers profited, with a median gain of $196,016. Sellers in California, particularly in San Jose (median gain: $695,000) and Anaheim (median gain: $510,000), are seeing the largest profits in the country.
For sellers concerned about market timing, the key is the length of homeownership. While short-term market fluctuations can impact those who sell quickly, historical data shows that real estate tends to appreciate over the long term. Prices in San Francisco have already rebounded from a low of $1.28 million in January 2023, indicating market volatility rather than a permanent decline.
Before listing your home, research recent comparable sales in your immediate neighborhood to set realistic price expectations. Understanding your local market's specific conditions is more important than national headlines. Consulting with a local real estate professional can provide tailored advice based on your property's unique characteristics and your financial timeline.









