Browse
Log in / Register
Share
The former Hamptons residence of legendary composer Marvin Hamlisch is now on the market for $3.95 million. This 200-year-old property on Captain's Row, built in 1840, offers a rare combination of historic provenance, vintage charm, and modern updates, featuring four bedrooms, three bathrooms, and unique amenities like a Prohibition-era speakeasy. For buyers seeking a home with character and a significant place in American arts history, this listing presents a distinctive opportunity.
What is the history and current state of this historic Hamptons home? Originally constructed in 1840, this property is a significant piece of Sag Harbor's architectural history. While it maintains its historic character, the home has been thoughtfully renovated since Marvin Hamlisch's tenure. The current layout offers 2,500 square feet of living space across multiple stories. The renovations have carefully preserved original details while incorporating contemporary comforts, resulting in a home that meets modern standards without sacrificing its 19th-century soul. The classic red-brick facade and lush greenery surrounding the property enhance its timeless curb appeal.
What are the key interior features and layout? Upon entry, a stunning foyer leads directly into a fireside parlor. The home is defined by its exposed-beam ceilings and rustic hardwood floors. The expansive living area features a light wood floor, a second fireplace, and classic crown molding. One of the four bedrooms has been converted into a den, which connects to the eat-in kitchen. The kitchen itself is a highlight, featuring an original fireplace and oven, an apron sink, and state-of-the-art appliances. The bathroom includes a charming claw-foot tub, reinforcing the vintage aesthetic.
What defines the primary suite and additional sleeping areas? An elegant staircase leads to the primary bedroom suite, which boasts a fireplace and a renovated bathroom. The primary bath is equipped with a heated floor, double vanities, and a glass-enclosed shower. Another sleeping area features a self-contained guest suite with a private staircase, a bedroom with a fireplace, and a marble bathroom. This layout offers flexibility for homeowners, providing privacy for guests or family members.
What unique amenities does the property offer? A standout feature is the attic, which houses a speakeasy dating to the Prohibition era. This unique space contains two fireplaces and serves as a remarkable conversation piece, directly linking the home to a specific period in American history. Outside, the grounds include a stunning garden, a plunge pool, and an outdoor shower. The landscaping provides numerous areas for both relaxing and entertaining guests, making the property ideal for enjoying the Hamptons lifestyle.
Is a historic home with celebrity provenance a good investment? Purchasing a historic home, especially one with a connection to a celebrated figure like Marvin Hamlisch, involves specific considerations. The property's provenance can add intangible value and appeal. However, potential buyers should always conduct a thorough inspection to understand the maintenance requirements associated with a 200-year-old structure. It is also advisable to research any local historic preservation guidelines that might affect future renovations.
