ok.com
Browse
Log in / Register

Gramercy Park Penthouse with Private Key Listed at $2.39 Million | 2026 Guide

OKer_9pef65f
01/11/2026, 11:13:35 PM
Gramercy Park Penthouse with Private Key Listed at $2.39 Million | 2026 Guide

A rare opportunity to own a piece of New York City history has emerged with the listing of a sunlit penthouse at 34 Gramercy Park for $2.39 million. This two-bedroom, one-bath unit, on the market for the first time since 1988, offers the highly exclusive benefit of a key to Gramercy Park, the city's only private park. The property shares its floor with a triplex owned by model and actress Cara Delevingne, adding to its unique appeal for buyers seeking a landmarked building with celebrity neighbors.

What Makes This Gramercy Park Penthouse Unique?

The apartment's standout feature is its deeded access to Gramercy Park, a gated private park accessible only to residents of the surrounding buildings. This is an exceptionally rare amenity in New York City. Beyond this, the unit boasts significant historical character, including four original wood-beamed skylights that flood the space with natural light. The home is located within a Queen Anne-style, landmarked building constructed in 1883, meaning its historic façade and certain architectural elements are protected by law. The building's lobby features a Tiffany glass ceiling and an original fireplace, reinforcing its historic pedigree.

What Are the Key Features and Layout of the Apartment?

The penthouse is designed to maximize both space and light. The main living area features stained-glass panels and custom-built bookshelves, with windows offering direct views of the park below. The kitchen includes windows and leads to a charming dormer space that functions as a breakfast nook with built-in bench seating and views stretching toward the Freedom Tower. The layout includes two bedrooms and one bathroom. A key real estate term to understand here is Freehold, which refers to outright ownership of the property and the land on which it stands; however, in this context, the apartment is likely a condominium (Condo), a type of ownership where you own your individual unit but share ownership of common areas with other residents.

FeatureDescription
Price$2,390,000
Bedrooms/Bathrooms2 / 1
Key AmenityDeeded Key to Gramercy Park
Architectural StyleLandmarked Queen Anne (built 1883)
Interior Highlights4 Skylights, Stained-Glass Panels, Custom Bookshelves

Who Has Owned Units in This Historic Building?

The building at 34 Gramercy Park has a long history of notable residents, which contributes to its prestige. The current seller is Dr. Robert Koehl, a professor of archaeology at Hunter College. The adjacent triplex was previously owned by television host Jimmy Fallon and was sold to Cara Delevingne in 2022 for $10.8 million. Past celebrity residents have included actors Richard Gere, James Cagney, and Margaret Hamilton. This history adds a layer of cultural significance to the property, though it is essential for buyers to focus on the physical attributes and legal terms of the sale, facilitated by a Title Insurance policy that protects against ownership disputes.

Is This a Good Investment in the Current Market?

Based on our experience assessment, properties with exclusive amenities like a Gramercy Park key tend to hold their value exceptionally well. The combination of historic status, unique features, and limited inventory of similar units creates a strong investment profile. The price per square foot appears to be in line with other premium, landmarked properties in the Gramercy Park neighborhood. When considering any New York City real estate purchase, it is crucial to account for monthly common charges and property taxes, which are ongoing costs associated with condominium ownership.

Purchasing a home in a landmarked building with such a unique amenity requires a focus on the property's tangible attributes, its legal standing, and the long-term value of its exclusivity. The current listing presents a compelling opportunity for a buyer seeking a one-of-a-kind piece of Manhattan real estate.

Cookie
Cookie Settings
Our Apps
Download
Download on the
APP Store
Download
Get it on
Google Play
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.