Share

The U.S. housing market saw bidding wars hit a 10-year low in late 2019, with only 10% of home offers facing competition. However, specific markets like San Francisco and San Jose defied seasonal trends with an unexpected uptick in competition, signaling a potential return to a seller's market in the year ahead, driven by low mortgage rates and a constrained supply of homes for sale.
What Was the National Rate of Bidding Wars in October 2019?
In October 2019, just 10 percent of offers written by Redfin agents faced a bidding war, a significant decrease from 39 percent a year earlier. This placed the national competition level at its lowest point in a decade. A bidding war occurs when multiple prospective buyers submit offers on the same property, often driving the final sale price above the initial listing price. This data, sourced from a major national real estate brokerage, indicates a broad cooling from the intensely competitive markets seen in previous years.
Which Metro Areas Had the Most Competitive Housing Markets?
Despite the national cooldown, four California metropolitan areas ranked among the top five most competitive markets. San Francisco led the nation with 34.8% of offers facing bidding wars, followed by San Jose (20.5%), San Diego (15.6%), and Los Angeles (13.7%). On the East Coast, Philadelphia was the only non-California market in the top five, with a competition rate of 13.8%. Notably, the rates in San Francisco and San Jose reached new highs for the 2019 calendar year in October, a month when market activity typically slows down.
Why Did Seattle's Market See Less Competition Than the National Average?
In a notable shift, the Seattle market's bidding war rate fell to 8.8 percent, which was below the national average. This represented a dramatic change for a city that was previously as competitive as its California counterparts. Based on our experience assessment, this allowed buyers more negotiating power, often enabling them to include standard sale contingencies, such as inspection and financing clauses, which are frequently waived in hotter markets to make an offer more attractive.
| Metro Area | Bidding War Rate (Oct 2019) |
|---|---|
| San Francisco, CA | 34.8% |
| Philadelphia, PA | 13.8% |
| Los Angeles, CA | 13.7% |
| San Diego, CA | 15.6% |
| San Jose, CA | 20.5% |
| National Average | 10.0% |
| Seattle, WA | 8.8% |
| Las Vegas, NV | 4.5% |
| Atlanta, GA | 3.8% |
| Miami, FL | 3.7% |
What Factors Point Toward a Return of Bidding Wars?
Industry analysis from the time pointed to specific economic conditions that suggested increased competition was likely. Low mortgage interest rates increased buying power, while a lower-than-usual inventory of homes for sale created a supply and demand imbalance. These factors were identified as key pieces that could shift the market back in favor of sellers. This environment indicated that the window for buyers to purchase a home without a bidding war might be closing.
For buyers in today's market, the key takeaway is to understand that local conditions can vary dramatically from national trends. While the overall market may cool, prime locations can remain highly competitive. Monitoring local inventory levels and mortgage rate trends provides the best insight into potential competition. For sellers, even in a cooler market, pricing a home correctly and ensuring it is well-marketed remain critical to attracting serious offers.









