ok.com
Browse
Log in / Register

Third Charged in Mistaken Identity Murder: Joshua Macdonald

OKer_evgoiqv
09/24/2026, 09:19:35 AM
Joshua Macdonald

As of Thursday, September 18, 2025, three people are now facing charges over the shooting death of 40-year-old Joshua Macdonald in Western Sydney, with police alleging a coordinated plot that ended in a case of mistaken identity. The latest suspect — a 21-year-old man arrested in Pemulwuy — is accused of being the getaway driver during the fatal attack on September 2.

Latest arrest: 21-year-old charged

The man was arrested at a property in Pemulwuy, in Sydney's west, at approximately 6am on Wednesday, September 17. He was later charged with murder, participating in a criminal group contributing to criminal activity, and failing to comply with a digital evidence access order direction.

He was refused bail and will appear before Parramatta Local Court on Thursday, September 18. Because murder carries a presumption against bail under New South Wales law, the man would have been required to "show cause" why his detention was not justified — a high legal hurdle he was unable to clear.

What police allege happened

The charges stem from the death of Macdonald, who was shot outside a home on Bruce Street in Merrylands West at about 3.15pm on September 2. CCTV recovered by investigators is said to show a car pulling up in front of the house and several shots being fired through the rear window.

Police have said from the outset that they believe the shooting was a mistaken-identity attack. That means Macdonald was likely not the intended target, and that the real target may have been linked to the address rather than to the man who died there.

Detectives from Fairfield City Police Area Command allege the 21-year-old drove the gunman to and from the scene of the shooting. He is also accused of driving other people involved in the alleged plot to destroy vehicles connected with the attack.

If that allegation holds up in court, the man's role was central: without a getaway driver, the alleged gunman would have had no way in or out of the area.

The drone operator already in custody

The 21-year-old is the third person to be charged. Jimmy Schulz, 18, was arrested at West Hoxton on September 11 after evidence recovered during the investigation allegedly implicated him in the shooting.

Police allege Schulz operated a drone during the incident. He has been charged with murder and remains before the courts.

The alleged use of a drone fits the mistaken-identity theory: if the attack involved aerial surveillance of a particular property, the shooting may have targeted the house rather than the person standing outside it.

The schoolteacher who allegedly acted as lookout

Ashleigh Ann Seeney, 28, a physical education teacher at Airds High School in Campbelltown, is the second accused. She has since been stood down from her teaching position.

Seeney was first arrested at a unit in Wollongong on Friday, September 12. Police allege she conducted surveillance for those involved in the shooting and helped them escape afterwards.

Initially, she was charged with being an accessory after the fact to murder, participating in a criminal group, and failing to comply with a digital evidence access order. She was granted bail at that stage.

But on Tuesday, September 16, Seeney was arrested again. This time, police charged her with conspiracy to murder, participating in a criminal group, and failing as an owner to disclose the identity of a driver or passenger. When she faced court on September 17, her previous bail was revoked.

She is now behind bars and is not due back before a judge until November 19.

Why the conspiracy charge matters

The shift from "accessory after the fact" to "conspiracy to murder" is legally significant. In New South Wales, conspiracy to murder carries a maximum penalty of 25 years' imprisonment.

An accessory-after-the-fact charge means police believe a person helped after the crime. A conspiracy charge means they believe the person was part of the planning before it — agreeing to the killing even if they did not pull the trigger.

Prosecutors typically lay conspiracy charges when the evidence points to a shared plan. In this case, the alleged elements — surveillance by Seeney, drone operation by Schulz, driving by the 21-year-old — would form the basis of a coordinated conspiracy.

The related charge of failing to disclose the identity of a driver or passenger is more administrative in nature. It suggests police believe Seeney was connected to a vehicle used in the crime but refused to say who was driving it.

Digital evidence access orders under scrutiny

All three accused face charges connected to digital evidence access orders. These are court-issued orders that compel a person to provide passwords, PINs or other material to help police access electronic devices.

Failing to comply with a direction under such an order is itself a criminal offence. That all three suspects have been hit with this charge suggests police hold devices they believe contain crucial evidence — and that none of the accused has been cooperative.

Key dates in the case

  • September 2 — Joshua Macdonald is shot and killed outside his home in Merrylands West.
  • September 11 — Jimmy Schulz is arrested at West Hoxton and charged with murder.
  • September 12 — Ashleigh Ann Seeney is first arrested in Wollongong and later granted bail.
  • September 16 — Seeney is rearrested on new charges, including conspiracy to murder.
  • September 17 — The 21-year-old man is arrested in Pemulwuy; Seeney's bail is revoked.
  • September 18 — The 21-year-old faces Parramatta Local Court.

Community impact and next steps

The case has rippled through several Sydney communities. NSW public schools typically stand down staff facing serious criminal charges while the matter is unresolved, which explains Seeney's removal from Airds High School.

The shooting has rattled the normally quiet suburb of Merrylands West, and the suggestion that the victim was killed by mistake has added to the unease among local residents.

Police have not ruled out further arrests. The investigation continues, with detectives still reviewing CCTV, mobile phone data and vehicle movements from the afternoon of September 2.

Anyone with dashcam or CCTV footage from Bruce Street, or from nearby roads in Merrylands West, around the time of the shooting is urged to contact Fairfield City Police Area Command or Crime Stoppers.

The next major court date is Seeney's reappearance on November 19. Before then, the 21-year-old's bail matter will be heard, and the brief of evidence against all three will continue to grow. For a case built on allegations of drones, surveillance, getaway driving and destroyed vehicles, the full picture is likely to take months to emerge in court.

Cookie
Cookie Settings
Our Apps
Download
Download on the
APP Store
Download
Get it on
Google Play
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.