Share

April 25, 2026 — A person riding in a private car does not qualify as a "third party" under the Motor Vehicles Act, the Himachal Pradesh High Court has ruled. Where the vehicle is covered only by an Act Policy — the statutory minimum insurance — and no additional premium is paid for occupants, the insurer has no obligation to compensate that passenger for death or bodily injury.
The judgment arrived in an appeal filed by New India Assurance Company Limited against an award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT), Sundernagar. Justice Sushil Kukreja, presiding as a Single Judge, allowed the appeal, exonerated the insurer, and directed disciplinary follow-up against the judicial officer who had passed the original order.
The case dates back to December 30, 2016. A 44-year-old painter, reportedly earning Rs 15,000 a month, died when the car he was traveling in rolled into fields at Beh-Ki-Dhar. His widow and son sought Rs 50 lakh in compensation, alleging that the driver had been rash and negligent.
On August 16, 2023, the MACT awarded Rs 13,93,100 — plus interest at 6 percent per annum — and directed the insurance company to pay. The tribunal held all respondents jointly and severally liable.
New India Assurance contested the award under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, arguing that the deceased was an occupant of a private car insured under a bare Act Policy. That type of policy, the company said, covers third-party risks only — not people traveling inside the insured vehicle.
The High Court found that the tribunal had relied on an insurance policy valid from September 3, 2015 to September 2, 2016. But the accident took place on December 30, 2016 — nearly four months after that policy had lapsed.
The policy in force on the date of the accident, valid from September 19, 2016 to September 18, 2017, was the one that should have been examined. The tribunal, the Court observed, had adjudicated the case on an expired document.
On the merits, the Court applied a settled line of Supreme Court precedents: United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Tilak Singh, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sudhakaran, New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Sadanand Mukhi, and National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Balakrishnan. Together, these cases establish that an Act Policy does not extend to gratuitous passengers in a private car unless the policy is specifically endorsed to cover them.
"The occupant of a private car does not fall within the definition of third party and is only a gratuitous passenger," Justice Kukreja observed, noting that no additional premium had been paid to cover the occupant's risk.
The Court also pointed to the premium record: only Rs 2,205 had been paid toward third-party cover. No rider or endorsement for occupants existed.
The High Court modified the award to the limited extent of exonerating the insurance company. The registered owner of the car — respondent No. 4 — was held liable to satisfy the award. All other terms of the tribunal's order, including the interest component, remained intact.
What makes this judgment notable is the Court's blunt assessment of the judicial officer who handled the case. Justice Kukreja said the award "clearly reflects total non-application of mind" and described the officer's approach as "highly objectionable."
The officer — now a District & Sessions Judge heading a district judiciary — was, according to the Court, unaware of the difference between an Act/Liability-only policy and a Comprehensive/Package policy. "Judicial orders cannot be allowed to be passed in a mechanical manner," the Court stated.
The High Court directed the officer to undergo a refresher course and periodic training at the H.P. State Judicial Academy in MACT matters. The Registrar General was instructed to place a copy of the judgment in the officer's service record and send another copy to the Academy's Director.
The confusion behind this case is common among Indian vehicle owners. An Act Policy, often called a Liability Only Policy, is the mandatory minimum cover required by law. It protects against claims by third parties — typically pedestrians, other vehicles, and their drivers or owners. It does not protect the people riding inside the insured car.
A Comprehensive Policy, by contrast, includes own-damage cover and can be extended to passengers — but only if an additional premium is paid for that specific risk. Without such an endorsement, even a comprehensive policy may not automatically cover every occupant.
Many motorists assume that "insurance" means everyone in the car is protected. This ruling is a reminder that coverage is contractual: if the risk isn't named in the policy and the premium hasn't been paid, the insurer's liability does not arise.
For the family of the deceased painter, the outcome is sobering. They still hold an award in their favor, but the money must now come from the car owner, not the insurance company. Whether they actually recover the full amount will depend on the owner's financial position.
For insurers, the judgment provides a usable precedent in similar MACT matters. It reinforces the argument that Act-only policies mark a clear boundary between third-party risks and occupant risks. Claims involving occupants of insured private vehicles may now face tougher scrutiny, with this decision cited as authority.
The case also carries a professional warning for claims tribunals across the country. The High Court's decision to place the judgment on the officer's service record sends a signal that careless adjudication in MACT matters will not be tolerated.
"The district judiciary is the bedrock of our judicial system," the Court noted, adding that an officer at the head of a district judiciary is expected to possess at least elementary knowledge of the Motor Vehicles Act.
The judgment was delivered in New India Assurance Company Limited v. Promila Devi and others, Neutral Citation No. 2026:HHC:47519.
Appearances: For the appellant — Raman Sethi, Advocate. For the respondents — Surender Verma, Kanishk Rohal, Vinay Sharma, Vinod Thakur, and Mohar Singh, Advocates.









