ok.com
Browse
Log in / Register

Long Island's Car-Centric Roads: Deadly Legacy, Transit Fix

OKer_y5eljgw
10/04/2026, 09:02:49 PM
Long Island car-centric roads

As of May 1, 2026, Long Island is still paying for a transportation decision made more than half a century ago: build for cars and let transit wait. A veteran journalist who first reported on the island in 1963 makes that case in a Newsday op-ed, arguing that Robert Moses' highway-first planning left a "dangerous legacy." The piece points to Suffolk County's grim record as New York's leader in traffic deaths and asks whether speed-limit laws and transit investment can finally undo the damage.

In the early 1960s, the reporter interviewed Austin M. Sarr, district engineer for the New York State Department of Public Works. Sarr described his version of traffic reality: a highway built to ease congestion on another road would soon be discovered by drivers and become congested itself. His advice was to give Long Island options—buses, trains, better connections—rather than simply pave more lanes. Transportation researchers now call that effect induced demand, and the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine has documented how road widening can generate extra vehicle travel, making any relief short-lived and expensive.

Robert Moses saw the world differently. Although he was chauffeured wherever he went, he made sure other New Yorkers lived by the automobile. The Southern State Parkway, Northern State Parkway and Long Island Expressway became the skeleton of the region, while funds that might have modernized rail lines went into road construction instead. For decades, the island's political establishment treated the car as the only realistic transport mode, and the consequences are still visible on every highway map.

There were attempts to change course. Suffolk County Executive Peter Cohalan wrote in his 1980 annual report that the county needed "an efficient and reliable mass transportation system," and Suffolk Transit soon followed. Suffolk lawmaker Lou Howard pushed for a monorail along the Long Island Expressway median. Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele, Jr., called for a regional network that would connect trains and buses. Each effort had local support, but none received the sustained state investment it needed to become the backbone of a real alternative.

The price is measured in lives. The University at Albany's Institute for Traffic Safety Management & Research routinely shows Suffolk County at or near the top of New York's annual traffic fatality totals. Long Island's road-death rate is about twice the statewide average, and excessive speed is one of the most frequent factors. Last week's news from Suffolk Police was a familiar example: a driver clocked at 106 mph on the Long Island Expressway near Exit 70.

Newsday's "Dangerous Roads" series has made the same point for years. Reporter Alfonso Castillo wrote that the LIE's straight-line promise has become a trap for drivers. On a 10-mile stretch, he noted, sticking to 55 mph takes about 10 minutes and 55 seconds. Going 75 mph saves less than three minutes but sharply increases the chance of a crash. That narrow time gain is what the roads still communicate to motorists: speed is worth the risk.

Castillo also tested the alternative. On last September's 14th annual Car Free Day, he took the Long Island Rail Road from his home in Valley Stream to Newsday's office in Melville. The trip that usually takes 40 minutes to an hour by car stretched to two hours and 10 minutes in one direction and roughly two hours and 45 minutes on the way back. The experiment was not an argument against transit. It was an illustration of how underfunded, circuitous and car-dependent the current system has become.

State leaders have started to reach for new tools. Gov. Kathy Hochul in March signed a law requiring drivers with 16 or more speed-camera violations in a year to install an Intelligent Speed Limiter in their vehicle. The GPS-linked device caps the car's speed at the posted limit. If the driver does not comply within 45 days, the vehicle registration can be suspended. The law is a clear signal that repeated speeding will no longer be treated as a benign habit.

But enforcement can only do so much. The Federal Highway Administration has published a "Toolbox of Individual Traffic Calming Measures," listing road designs that make high speeds feel uncomfortable. Roundabouts, speed bumps, speed humps and speed tables are all designed to protect people outside cars. A speed table is a flat-topped strip roughly three inches high and 22 feet long; it forces attention without the jolt of a traditional bump. On Noyac Road in Southampton Town, artist Dorothy Frankel has urged officials to install speed tables because cars routinely race along the curvy two-lane road despite a 30 mph limit. A sign, she argues, cannot do a police officer's job forever.

County Executive Ed Romaine used his September 4, 2025 State of the County address to echo the same themes. He spoke of clogged highways, incomplete LIRR double tracking, the need for electrification and the urgency of linking buses and trains. "This should not be car-centric," he said. The words amount to a public rebuke of the Robert Moses era, but rebuilding transit after a generation of underinvestment will take more than a single budget cycle.

For the journalist behind the op-ed, the issue is personal. For 47 years, he taught at SUNY Old Westbury while living on the other side of the island. The 75-mile drive on the Long Island Expressway was a constant test of patience and personal safety. He watched drivers weave in and out at 85 mph, treating the highway like a speedway. The dangerous road legacy is not an abstraction to him; it is the commute he survived.

The challenge now is whether Long Island can break its dependence on the expressway mentality. Speed limiters for repeat offenders can help. Traffic-calming hardware can protect neighborhoods. Better bus connections, electrified rail and seamless links between modes can offer a genuine choice instead of a forced one. But none of those measures will replace the difficult conversation about why car-centric planning was allowed to dominate for so long.

On May 1, 2026, the island's unsafe road reputation is not ancient history—it is the current result of old decisions. The roads built for another era still shape how people live, work and risk their lives. Sarr's Law has been validated over and over. The next generation of transportation should not be another monument to Robert Moses.

Cookie
Cookie Settings
Our Apps
Download
Download on the
APP Store
Download
Get it on
Google Play
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.