Share

As of March 10, 2025, Haddon Township residents continue to voice strong opposition to the police department’s network of 24 stationary automatic license plate reader (ALPR) cameras, a debate that first erupted during a commissioners meeting in August 2023. More than half a dozen community members raised concerns Tuesday, Aug. 25, 2023, about the technology’s accuracy, its potential for mass surveillance, and the long-term use of the collected data. The controversy highlights a growing tension between law enforcement’s investigative needs and residents’ fears of overreach, a tension that is now playing out in towns across New Jersey.
Police Chief Tim Hak defended the cameras as a valuable investigative tool, emphasizing that they help officers identify vehicles linked to reported crimes, recover stolen cars, and respond to alerts for missing persons. He stressed that the township owns the data from its Axon-brand cameras and that access is strictly governed by New Jersey regulations. “Officers cannot randomly search the data hoping to find a crime,” Hak said. “An investigation starts with a specific complaint and a lead that narrows the search—like a partial plate, a time frame, or a location.” He cited a recent arrest related to lewd conduct with juveniles as an example of how the cameras reduced investigative hours, though he declined to discuss the active case.
Surveillance and Accuracy Remain Flashpoints
Julia D’Amico of Westmont Avenue warned that AI-powered plate reader systems can cause real harm, pointing to out-of-state incidents where the technology led to mistaken detentions, incorrect charges, and misuse by an officer accused of stalking an ex-wife. Although Flock Safety cameras have drawn the most public scrutiny nationwide, speakers noted that switching to Axon did not resolve their fundamental concerns. “The platform is capable of much more than what’s currently restricted,” said Betsy Campbell, a mother of young children. “New uses of the data could leave the township always playing catch-up.”
Tom MacAlpine, a former Woodlynne police officer, said he supports officers using ALPRs from patrol vehicles but objected to stationary cameras that continuously collect vehicle information along local roads. He argued that the AI could be used to build detailed records of people’s daily movements and eventually support broader enforcement, including automated ticketing. “Once the infrastructure is in place, it’s easy to expand its use without public debate,” he said.
Chief Details Restrictions and Use Cases
Chief Hak explained that the system’s primary value is reducing investigative hours. When a stationary reader detects a vehicle flagged in a be-on-the-lookout (BOLO) alert, officers on patrol receive real-time guidance to the area. Stolen vehicles are the most common alerts, and quick response helps prevent additional crimes and returns vehicles to owners undamaged. The system also aids Amber Alerts for abducted children, Silver Alerts for missing seniors with dementia, and criminal BOLOs that may cross state lines.
Commissioner Ryan Linhart asked whether the cameras could be used for federal immigration enforcement. Hak pointed to the state attorney general’s









