ok.com
Browse
Log in / Register

Biddeford ICE shooting reignites debate on vehicle fire tactics, training gaps

OKer_yin8ive
07/28/2026, 11:03:10 PM
Biddeford shooting

May 14, 2025 – The fatal shooting of Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero by federal immigration agents in Biddeford earlier this month has reignited a national debate over the tactics and training of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers, particularly when it comes to firing at moving vehicles. The incident marked the fifth time since January that immigration officials have killed someone behind the wheel, and the second time in less than a week agents fired at a vehicle.

The Department of Homeland Security’s use-of-force policy allows agents to shoot at a moving vehicle only if a person inside poses an imminent threat of death or serious injury through means other than the vehicle itself, or if the vehicle’s operation threatens to cause death or serious physical injury. Yet enforcement data compiled by The Trace shows that since 2025, federal immigration agents have shot or claimed to have shot at a moving vehicle 20 times. More than half of those cases began as routine traffic stops.

In Maine, local, state and federal officers have shot at vehicles at least 24 times since 2002, according to a Maine Monitor analysis of state attorney general reports. Four of those incidents were fatal; 11 others caused injuries. No officers died. In all 24 cases, the attorney general ruled the use of force justified, often relying heavily on officers’ perception of potential harm.

Police reform advocates say that standard is too lenient. “Only if a vehicle is being used as a ramming device should police shoot at it,” said Chuck Wexler, executive director of the Police Executive Research Forum. “Otherwise you risk lives unnecessarily.”

A key issue is the lack of body cameras on ICE agents. Despite a pledge after two deadly Minneapolis shootings in January to deploy them nationwide, adoption remains spotty. In several documented cases, bystander video has contradicted official accounts of vehicle shootings.

After the Biddeford shooting, DHS announced it would halt all non-emergency traffic stops, but President Donald Trump quickly reversed that order, calling stops “one of the most effective crime-fighting tools.” In a CNN interview, border czar Tom Homan said the agency had made “immediate changes,” including requiring at least one body camera at every operation. But critics note the policy lacks enforcement mechanisms.

Law enforcement training expert Noel March, who served in the U.S. Marshals Service and now directs the University of Maine at Augusta’s Community Policing Institute, said officers are taught a “continuum of force” that escalates from presence to lethal action. But he warned that rapid hiring—ICE has added 12,000 new agents since January 2025—could strain training quality. “Speed of expansion can undercut the depth of judgment needed in high-stress situations,” March said.

Brunswick Police Chief Scott Stewart, president of the Maine Chiefs of Police Association, declined to comment on the Biddeford case specifically but said officers are trained to de-escalate whenever possible. “Situations unravel fast,” he said. “But training should emphasize that shooting at a vehicle is almost never the right answer.”

As state and federal inquiries continue, the circumstances of Durán Guerrero’s death remain murky. What is clear, experts say, is that the pattern of vehicle shootings by ICE demands a systemic review—not just of policy, but of the culture and training that allow such incidents to recur.

Cookie
Cookie Settings
Our Apps
Download
Download on the
APP Store
Download
Get it on
Google Play
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.