Share

March 8, 2025
What is the best car ever? It's a question that stirs passion, sparks barstool arguments, and divides families. Unlike a technical specification sheet, the "best car" can't be measured in horsepower alone — it's about emotion, reliability, cultural impact, and personal memory. Today, we’re launching an open forum: no rules, no categories, just your honest opinion. Email elawrence@freepress.com with your pick and why. But first, let’s examine the strongest contenders that consistently top enthusiast polls and expert rankings.
Few nameplates evoke the spirit of American freedom like the Ford Mustang. Since its debut in 1964, the Mustang has defined the affordable pony car segment. From the original 260‑cubic‑inch V8 to the current Shelby GT500’s 760‑horsepower supercharged fury, it offers accessible performance for every generation. In 2024, the Mustang still outsold the Chevrolet Camaro and Dodge Challenger combined. Its continuous production run, cultural appearances in movies like Bullitt and Gone in 60 Seconds, and a loyal global fanbase make it a perennial candidate. Proponents argue that no other car democratized speed while maintaining an unmistakable style.
If the best car means the one that serves the most people for the longest time, the Toyota Corolla is a compelling argument. Over 50 million Corollas have been sold worldwide — more than any other car model in history. It’s not flashy, but it starts every morning, sips fuel, and often runs past 200,000 miles with basic maintenance. In 2025, the Corolla received a refreshed hybrid powertrain that achieves 53 mpg combined. Consumer Reports consistently rates it as one of the most reliable vehicles on the road. For millions of families, the Corolla is the car that gets the job done without drama — and that kind of dependability has its own heroic quality.
For driving purists, the Porsche 911 represents the pinnacle of sports car engineering. Since 1963, the 911’s rear‑engine layout has evolved from a sometimes‑tricky tail‑happy beast into a finely balanced precision instrument. The 2025 911 Carrera S still uses a twin‑turbo flat‑six that rewards experienced drivers while offering surprising everyday usability. Its racing pedigree — including multiple Le Mans class wins and countless rally victories — adds a layer of credibility that few road cars can claim. Enthusiast magazines from Car and Driver to Top Gear have frequently named it the best sports car ever. Those who vote for the 911 often cite its ability to improve with age without losing its soul.
While sports cars focus on pavement, the Jeep Wrangler explores everywhere else. The Wrangler’s lineage traces back to the WWII Willys MB, and its body‑on‑frame construction, solid axles, and removable doors/roof remain unique in the modern market. The Wrangler 4xe plug‑in hybrid, introduced in 2021 and refined for 2025, now offers 49 MPGe while retaining genuine trail capability. It’s the only vehicle that can go from a Rubicon trail to a suburban school run without compromise. The Wrangler community is fiercely loyal — owners wave to each other, mod their rigs endlessly, and pass them down through generations. For those who value adventure over speed, the Wrangler is the undisputed best car ever.
No list of the “best car ever” can ignore the paradigm shift caused by Tesla. The Model Y became the best‑selling vehicle in the world in 2023, and by early 2025 it remains in the top three globally. It redefined what an electric vehicle can be: fast (Plaid version does 0–60 in 3.5 seconds), practical (up to 330 miles range), and constantly improving via over‑the‑air updates. Tesla’s Supercharger network, now open to other brands under the NACS standard, addresses the biggest barrier to EV adoption. Critics point to build quality inconsistencies, but supporters argue that the Model Y accelerated the world’s transition to sustainable transport more than any single car before it.
In a 2024 survey by Hagerty of classic car owners, the Porsche 911 narrowly edged the Ford Mustang as the “most desirable collector car.” Meanwhile, Autotrader’s “Best Car Ever” reader poll from early 2025 showed the Toyota Corolla leading among drivers over 45, while Gen Z voters overwhelmingly favored the Tesla Model 3/Y. This generational divide highlights how “best” is deeply personal.
“The best car ever isn’t a spec sheet contest,” says automotive historian Dr. Sarah Chen of the University of Michigan. “It’s about the vehicle that defined a moment in your life — the first car you fell in love with, the one that took your family on road trips, or the machine that taught you how to drive.”
No debate is complete without underdogs. The Mazda MX‑5 Miata — the world’s best‑selling two‑seater roadster — deserves a shout for pure driving joy. The Volkswagen Beetle, with 21 million units sold and a cultural footprint from Woodstock to Herbie, has a solid claim. The Honda Civic, the Subaru Outback, the Chevrolet Corvette, and the original Mini Cooper each have passionate followings.
We want to hear from you. There are no restrictions — year, make, model, country of origin, price class, or propulsion type. The best car ever is your call. Send your choice along with a brief explanation (100 words or fewer) to elawrence@freepress.com. The most compelling arguments will be featured in a follow‑up article later this month.
Don’t overthink it. Is it the car you lusted after as a teenager? The one that never left you stranded? The one that makes you turn around and smile after parking it? That’s the best car ever — and you decide.
This article is part of an ongoing audience‑interaction series. All opinions expressed in submissions are those of the readers and not necessarily those of the publication.









