Share

April 10, 2025 – A senior U.S. Forest Service commander who fought repeated California wildfires says the nation’s strategy of extinguishing every blaze is merely “deferring risk,” leaving forests primed for even larger disasters.
Dan Dallas, an incident commander and the agency’s Rocky Mountain region director of renewable resources, had a wake-up call while managing a California fire, according to reporting from Grist. During wet, mild weather, Dallas, the local forest supervisor, and the Karuk Tribe agreed not to suppress the entire fire immediately, allowing it to creep across the forest floor and consume decades of built-up fuel—the legacy of relentless firefighting.
That controlled burn changed his outlook. “Finally, I figured out all I’m doing is deferring risk to this place,” Dallas told Grist. “I’m going to come back and protect it again.” His experience reflects a growing consensus among fire scientists: the very success of fire suppression creates the conditions for catastrophic megafires.
The suppression paradox
Ecologists have long understood that wildfires are a natural part of forest life cycles, clearing out dead brush, fallen trees, and dense undergrowth. When agencies put out fires quickly, that fuel stays on the ground, accumulating year after year. Then, when hot, dry, windy weather hits, any spark can ignite a blaze no one can control.
Matt Hurteau, a forest ecologist at the University of New Mexico, told Grist that federal teams stop more than 98% of wildfires. That near-perfect record, however, means fuel loads keep growing. “We keep going back to the same places, and it’s more often that the fires are more severe,” Dallas said.
A 2015 Forest Service futures report already warned that “the existing fire suppression approach will fail across the whole range of plausible future conditions,” per Grist. Yet, nearly a decade later, the Trump administration has shifted back toward a “full suppression” strategy that prioritizes extinguishing all blazes, including those not threatening lives or property.
Policy mismatch and budget gaps
Fire scientists urge a different approach: use more fire, not less. “No two ways about it. Science will tell you, you need more fire on the landscape,” Adam Mendonca, the Forest Service’s deputy director of Fire and Aviation Management, told Grist. That means prescribed burns, mechanical fuel reduction, and allowing some naturally ignited fires to burn in safe locations.
But the scale of prescribed burning remains far below what experts say is necessary. In fiscal year 2025, the Forest Service treated about 1.2 million acres with prescribed fire, down from 2.2 million acres in 2024. The drop reflects chronic underfunding and staffing shortages. Emergency money flows easily to suppression efforts, while preventive work depends on annual budgets and often uses the same personnel who are later pulled to fight active fires.
Dallas described the system as overwhelmed: “Our system is taxed beyond capacity to respond. It’s already falling apart.”
Current challenges and new pressures
Recent events highlight the urgency. In January 2025, the Palisades Fire in Los Angeles County burned over 4,000 acres and forced mass evacuations, fueled by extreme drought and dense vegetation. That same month, California lawmakers struggled to pass an overhaul of wildfire response, with some residents resisting new mitigation zones on private property. Homeowners also pushed back against proposed regulations that would require fire-resistant landscaping, arguing costs were too high.
Meanwhile, wildfire losses continue to drive up insurance premiums even for homeowners in states like Iowa, underscoring how far the risk of megafires has spread.
Researchers warn that contamination from recent fires—like the Park Fire of 2024—threatens drinking water supplies, with toxic ash and sediment seeping into reservoirs.
What can be done?
Making homes more fire-resistant—using non-combustible roofing, clearing vegetation around structures, and keeping defensible space—can help. But residents still depend on agencies to protect them from out-of-control blazes.
The core solution, scientists say, is scaling up prescribed burns and forest thinning. The Forest Service, working with tribes and state agencies, needs sustained funding and a dedicated workforce for prevention, not just for suppression.
“It’s not about zero fires—it’s about managing fires better,” Dallas said. For communities across the West, the question is whether policymakers will heed that warning before the next megafire proves the point.
For further reading:









