Browse
Log in / Register
Share
A home’s status changing to sale pending is a significant milestone, indicating the seller has accepted an offer. However, a growing number of these agreements collapse before closing. Recent data from the National Association of Realtors® shows that in May 2025, approximately 6% of pending home sales were canceled. This trend, driven by high mortgage rates and affordability pressures, highlights the fragility of real estate transactions. Based on expert analysis, the five most common reasons a pending sale fails are buyer's remorse, financing issues, problematic home inspections, contingent home sales, and low appraisals.
Buyer’s remorse is a common emotional response to a major financial decision. In a competitive market, buyers often feel pressured to make quick offers, which can lead to second-guessing after the fact. Most purchase agreements include contingencies—clauses that allow a buyer to back out under specific conditions without penalty. Many states also have a statutory due diligence period, a set number of days after contract signing during which a buyer can cancel for nearly any reason. While these safeguards protect buyers, they also mean a sale is not guaranteed until all contingencies are removed or expired.
Most home purchases are financed with a mortgage, and a failed loan application is a primary reason deals fall apart. If a buyer’s offer includes a financing contingency and their loan is not approved, they can typically cancel the contract and reclaim their earnest money deposit. Financing issues can arise from changes in a buyer’s financial profile, such as opening new credit accounts or making large purchases before closing, which can affect their debt-to-income (DTI) ratio. Lenders may also change their underwriting standards. In such cases, buyers can explore alternative financing options, like bank statement loans, and sellers may be willing to extend the closing date to help the sale proceed.
A home inspection is a critical step, providing a professional assessment of a property's condition. If significant defects are found—such as structural issues or faulty systems—a buyer can negotiate repairs or cancel the contract under an inspection contingency. Government-backed loans like FHA loans require a more stringent inspection by a certified technician; failure to meet these standards can terminate the sale. To save a deal, buyers can negotiate for the seller to complete repairs or provide a home warranty, which offers protection against future system failures for a set period.
Some buyers make their offer contingent on the successful sale of their current home. A home sale contingency allows them to back out if their existing property isn't sold by a specified date. This can create a chain of dependency that risks the entire transaction. Strategies to manage this include adjusting closing dates for coordination or obtaining a bridge loan, a short-term loan that provides funds to purchase a new home before the current one sells. This option requires strong financial standing but can keep the purchase on track.
Lenders require an appraisal—an independent assessment of a property’s market value—to ensure the loan amount is justified. If the appraisal value comes in below the agreed-upon purchase price, a significant gap is created. The buyer may need to pay the difference in cash, which can be challenging. Experts suggest that covering a gap of up to $10,000 can be reasonable if the buyer believes in the home's long-term value. However, if the gap is too large, the buyer may choose to walk away, as the lender will not finance the full amount.
To navigate a pending sale successfully, both buyers and sellers should understand these common pitfalls. For buyers, maintaining financial stability during the process and thoroughly reviewing inspection reports is crucial. For sellers, being flexible with timelines and considering negotiation on repair requests can help ensure the deal reaches closing. A clear understanding of contract contingencies protects all parties involved.
