Which Three-Row SUV Has the Best Cargo Space? A 2017 Challenge Reveals the Winner.

In a 2017 comparison of popular three-row SUVs, the Volkswagen Atlas was judged to have the most usable cargo space despite the Chevrolet Traverse having a superior paper specification. While cubic feet measurements provide a baseline, real-world testing with everyday items like golf bags and a large TV box proved that intelligent packaging and a thoughtful layout are more critical than raw volume alone.

How Was the Cargo Space in These Three-Row SUVs Measured?

Comparing SUVs solely by their listed "maximum cargo capacity in cubic feet" can be misleading. Cargo specifications are difficult to translate into usable real-world space. To provide a clearer picture, the testers conducted practical evaluations using two standard golf bags and a large, expandable cargo box representing a flat-screen TV package.

The tested models and their official maximum cargo capacities were:

Which SUV Actually Held the Most Real-World Cargo?

The real-world test revealed surprises that the paper specs did not show. The Traverse and Atlas, the two SUVs with the largest specifications, were the only ones capable of fitting the two golf bags side-by-side behind the raised third-row seat. In the Pilot and Highlander, the bags had to be stacked on top of each other to close the liftgate.

When the second and third-row seats were folded down, all four SUVs could accommodate the large cardboard box. However, the Volkswagen Atlas "swallowed it up with the most room to spare," leading expert judges to rate it as having the roomiest cargo area, followed by the Traverse, Pilot, and Highlander. This demonstrates that a well-designed cargo bay can often outperform a simply larger one.

Beyond Space: What Convenience Features Matter?

Having a large cargo area is one thing; using it conveniently is another. The vehicle with the best cargo room is ultimately the one that fits your belongings most easily and securely. Based on our assessment experience, here are key features that differ between these models:

• Hidden Storage: The Chevrolet Traverse and Honda Pilot offer valuable hidden storage bins in the rear cargo floor. This is an important feature for securing valuables like laptops or cameras out of sight. The Pilot's storage cover has a bonus feature: it can be flipped over to reveal a hard-plastic surface that is easier to clean.
• Cargo Cover Storage: Each SUV includes a retractable cargo cover for privacy. However, only the Toyota Highlander had a dedicated spot to store the cover within the vehicle when it's not needed. The other models require you to leave it at home or let it sit loosely in the cargo area.
• Power Outlets: For powering accessories on the go, the Traverse and Pilot are equipped with 12-volt power outlets in the cargo area. The Atlas has an outlet for third-row passengers that can be reached when the third row is folded down.
• Upholstery Protection: The second-row seatbacks in the Traverse and Atlas feature more durable, cargo-area-friendly fabric that extends to the top of the seats. In the Pilot and Highlander, the softer seat fabric is exposed when the seats are folded, making it susceptible to scuffs and tears from loading cargo; the Highlander in the test already showed signs of wear in this spot.

The most practical three-row SUV for you depends on how you plan to use the space. If sheer, easily accessible volume is the top priority, the Volkswagen Atlas stands out. If you frequently carry valuables that need to be concealed, the hidden storage of the Traverse or Pilot is a significant advantage. For those who value neatness, the Highlander’s integrated cargo cover storage is a thoughtful touch.