Which 3-Row SUV Won the 2016 Comparison Test for Families?

The 2016 Honda Pilot scored a decisive victory with 782 points in a rigorous eight-SUV comparison test, outperforming rivals like the GMC Acadia and Kia Sorento by offering minivan-like practicality in a more desirable SUV body. This comprehensive evaluation, conducted by a panel of expert editors and a real family, assessed vehicles on criteria including value, family-friendly features, driving dynamics, and fuel economy, all priced under $45,000.

What Were the Key Factors in Choosing the Best 3-Row SUV?

The test was designed to identify the best all-around vehicle for family life. Judges evaluated each SUV on a blend of objective and subjective metrics, with scoring weighted heavily (72%) towards expert assessment of ride quality, interior comfort, technology, and safety. Real-world fuel economy from a 170-mile drive accounted for 10% of the score, while feedback from an in-market family with two young children contributed the remaining 18%. The key was finding a vehicle that balanced space, comfort, and smart features without sacrificing driving enjoyment.

How Did the 2016 Honda Pilot Earn the Top Spot?

The Honda Pilot was praised for its exceptional attention to detail and family-centric design. Its cabin was noted for being light, airy, and incredibly spacious, with clever storage solutions throughout. A major advantage was its versatile seating; the second-row seats feature a one-button slide-and-fold function for easy third-row access, and it was the only SUV in the test that could fit three child-safety seats across the second row. Judges also highlighted the abundance of USB ports and the available rear-seat entertainment system. However, the Pilot wasn't perfect; its push-button gear selector and nine-speed automatic transmission were criticized for being unintuitive and occasionally slow to respond.

Which Other SUVs Were Strong Contenders?

The competition was tight, with several models offering compelling strengths.

• #2 2017 GMC Acadia (763 points): The redesigned Acadia was lauded for its agile handling and classy, user-friendly interior. Its standard Teen Driver system and rear climate control lock were standout family features. Downsides included a narrow pathway to the third row and less cargo space than its predecessor.
• #3 2017 Kia Sorento (735 points): The Sorento impressed with its quiet, comfortable ride and an impressive list of standard features for the price, including advanced safety tech and a panoramic moonroof. Its main drawbacks were a cramped third row and minimal cargo space behind it.
• #4 2016 Mazda CX-9 (715 points): This SUV stood out for its upscale, Audi-like interior and engaging driving dynamics, making it the sportiest choice. The trade-off was a very small third row suitable only for occasional use by children.

What Were the Common Strengths and Weaknesses Found?

Across the board, the best SUVs shared several traits. Strong V-6 engines (or a potent turbocharged four-cylinder in the CX-9) were essential for confident merging and highway passing. Easy-to-use infotainment systems with physical knobs, like Ford's Sync 3 and Dodge's Uconnect, were strongly preferred over touchscreen-only setups. Conversely, common flaws included transmissions that were slow to respond or frequently "hunted" for the right gear, and third-row seats that were often cramped and lacked basic amenities like air vents or charging ports.

What Practical Advice Can Shoppers Take From This Test?

Based on this extensive evaluation, families should prioritize a few key areas. Focus on real-world usability: test the third-row access with a child seat installed and check for sufficient cargo space behind the third row. Don't assume a higher price tag guarantees more features; the Nissan Pathfinder, for example, lacked a moonroof even in a $40,000-plus trim. The most successful models balanced practical family needs with a pleasant driving experience, proving that you don't have to sacrifice everything for space.

For families seeking the ultimate blend of space, smart features, and reliability, the 2016 Honda Pilot emerged as the clear winner. However, shoppers who value driving engagement might prefer the Mazda CX-9, while those seeking value should closely consider the Kia Sorento. The best choice ultimately depends on which strengths align most closely with your family's specific daily needs.